4 ms·
and why not the sneaky U.S.?
by jbverschoor 12y ago
and why not the sneaky U.S.?
- knd775 12y agoWhat would there be to be gained from that?
- Sanddancer 12y agoBecause it was operating fairly calmly on the surface, which strongly suggests that it was a diesel boat. Nuclear subs stay submerged after leaving port to help keep stealth. Diesel subs, on the other hand, have to either surface, or extend a snorkel, in order to pull in air to run the engines to recharge the batteries. The US, like the UK, and France has a pure-nuclear submarine fleet; the last American diesel boat was taken out of commission in the nineties. This leaves countries like Germany, whose boats have a distinctive profile that the photographed boat doesn't have, and Russia.
- pge 12y agoIn your comment about Germany, are you referring to the Type 209? My data is very dated (1997), but at that point, there were a lot of German-made diesels owned by other nations (including Argentina in the Falklands War). They are/were the Ak-47 of submarines, and many were substantially upgraded with things like Stirling engines so they could remain submerged longer. Point being, if it is a diesel (and I agree with your assessment that it is), it would be difficult to tell visually what nation it comes from, because many older diesels (particularly the German ones but also other) have been sold off and ended up in the fleets of various other countries.
- Sanddancer 12y agoYou've got a point, there. I was mostly trying to point out that pretty much everyone else in the general neighborhood is nuclear-only. It could potentially be a Venezuelan sub, but I wouldn't put them high on the list of countries willing to do a stunt like this.
- pge 12y agoFormer Eastern Bloc nations or Soviet republics? I agree with you that the intersection of countries still using diesels and countries that would be poking around Sweden is a small set - no obvious candidates, unless the rumors are true that Russia has been unable to keep their nuclear fleet operational and has reverted to diesels.
- wil421 12y agoWe havent been the ones doing bombing runs [1], sending transport planes [2] in European airspace or sending long range bombers to the Gulf of Mexico recently[3]. Besides we wouldnt send a sub to get intel when we have the Internet and the Swedes are already helping us [4]. [1]http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/europe/nato-says-russian-jets-bombers-circle-europe-in-unusual-incidents/2014/10/29/6098d964-5f97-11e4-827b-2d813561bdfd_story.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/europe/nato-says-russian... [2]http://news.yahoo.com/dutch-nato-f-16s-intercept-russian-transport-plane-195923222.html http://news.yahoo.com/dutch-nato-f-16s-intercept-russian-tra... [3]http://www.cnn.com/2014/11/13/world/europe/russia-bombers-plan/index.html http://www.cnn.com/2014/11/13/world/europe/russia-bombers-pl... [4]http://www.thelocal.se/20131211/sweden-aided-in-nsa-hacking-operations-report http://www.thelocal.se/20131211/sweden-aided-in-nsa-hacking-...
- cmdkeen 12y agoBecause they don't operate SSKs any more, same reason it isn't the sneaky UK. Both of whom are accused of operating in Russian waters, but those decisions are made at the very top of the political hierarchy on a per-mission basis. Doing so inside Swedish waters is incredibly unlikely due to the massive political fallout for negligible reward. Edit to add: SSK due to the size and operating on the bottom. "Small U boats" are SSKs (diesel electric) not SSNs, as the nuclear power plant is massive.