4 ms·
Nice, but I don't think the problem with soft edges are ever going to be solved satisfactorily. For instance, check the halo on the guy's hair next to the cabin
by tambourine_man 12y ago
Nice, but I don't think the problem with soft edges are ever going to be solved satisfactorily. For instance, check the halo on the guy's hair next to the cabinet in your example. Or the shirt/cabinet edge. Besides, it looks like gaussian, not lens blur, in the background.
Even manually Photoshoped images often don't look perfect.
I think we simply need more data, it can't be done convincingly with a single lens/aperture shot. Maybe with multiple shots/focus points, but even then, I'm skeptical.
- rdb 12y agoWe're primarily targeting providing depth of field adjustment tools for video as having multiple frames of data to work with obviously makes the task easier (although we can still get great results with a single image). We're also experimenting with other filters, not just Gaussian - it's the depth extraction part that we've been trying to innovate on.
- tambourine_man 12y agoRight, because it's the depth extraction part that's really hard. Particularly, the transitions. I haven't seen anything that struck me as natural, but I'd love to be proven wrong.