3 ms·
> The UI is a complete mess. Isn't that kind of subjective? And as long as we're being subjective: It's got my favorite comment UI of any given news site - bu
by pavel_lishin 12y ago
> The UI is a complete mess.
Isn't that kind of subjective?
And as long as we're being subjective: It's got my favorite comment UI of any given news site - built in comment collapsing, ability to link to specific comments with parent context, flexibility in URLs, etc.
HN could stand to borrow some of these improvements.
- scelerat 12y agoI wish reddit would remember my folds / unfolds per comment thread. Always stinks to read the comments, collapse some of the discussion for readability, click a link and then return to find the entire thread expanded again.
- skeletonjelly 12y agoSimplest solution I've found to this is just use your browser tabs.
- pavel_lishin 12y agoThat doesn't really scale well, however - if you're reading dozens of threads over the course of a few days, well, good luck.
- skeletonjelly 12y agoIn that case I'm pretty sure RES saves the state of the collapsed threads.
- pavel_lishin 12y agoYup, it does.
- pavel_lishin 12y agoI agree, that would be nice - for now, I use RES[1] which provides this. [1] http://redditenhancementsuite.com/ http://redditenhancementsuite.com/
- dang 12y ago> HN could stand to borrow some of these improvements Which ones, besides comment collapsing (which we definitely intend to do)?
- karissa 12y agohow long does it take to write a comment collapser? -_-?
- dang 12y agoI'm sure most people here could do it in a couple hours or a weekend.
- pavel_lishin 12y agoAnd they have; there's an extension for it. But it would be nice if it were baked in.
- pavel_lishin 12y agoBeing able to link to a specific comment, with a context history. Right now, I can link to a comment, but you have to keep clicking "parent" to understand the full conversation.
- dang 12y agoAs an occasional Reddit user, I find that particular feature rather confusing. If anyone wants to suggest a "native" way to do it on HN, i.e. that would fit with the existing design and be simple and intuitive, please email hn@ycombinator.com and we can talk about it offline.
- krapp 12y agoI personally find it annoying when I follow a comment parent by parent only to have to find the original comment somewhere inside what turns out to be a really large thread. Something as simple as having a link to the original post in each comment might help navigation a bit too.