5 ms·
Why 5 cent charges for plastic bags work
- gxs 12y agoPerhaps I've grown too cynical in my old age, but I always figured this was just the grocery lobbies' doing. We could outright ban the bags (which we have for plastic, not paper). Instead, they literally nickel and dime you every time you shop. Sure 10 cents a bag isn't a big deal, but 3-4 across millions of customers per year, and now you're talking serious cash.
- FreakyT 12y agoIn the article, they note that a study found that the small plastic bag charges tended to strongly influence behavior without an outright ban. Personally, I see it as a win/win. The grocery stores get more money from people obsessed with plastic bags, and the municipality reduces the number of plastic bags wasted.
- gxs 12y agoI actually did read the article and saw that. That tidbit was interesting. I understand your view and hence why I called myself cynical.
- pathdependent 12y agoI just moved up from DC to NJ. It definitely modified by behavior. Down there, I didn't want to pay the five cent tax. (IIRC, I think the five cents went to Chesapeake Bay cleanup or something like that. It wasn't more money for the store.) Now that I am in NJ -- where there is no tax -- I still instinctually say, "no bag, thanks."
- scotty79 12y agoIt strongly affects behavior but also perception of shopping, making it even more miserable.
- threeseed 12y agoIn your opinion. We have had a similar policy here in Australia for many years and it has had no impact to consumer confidence or shopping behaviour. People who find the concept to be miserable should rethink their attitude.
- waterlesscloud 12y agoOr perhaps they should remain free to have whatever response they have rather than the one you feel they 'should' have.
- eli 12y agoYes, I think you are being cynical. If grocers wanted people to use fewer bags, they didn't need to ask the government to create a new tax. They could have simply started charging for them, which would have reduced demand AND they'd get to keep all the nickels and dimes it brings in AND there's no risk of a fine for forgetting to do it. Also I wouldn't assume that a ban would be more effective than a tax.
- fps 12y agomost grocery stores in the northeast discount you 5 cents for each re-usable bag you use, all on their own. they've done this for at least a decade. the bags aren't cheap, and the grocery store bundles the cost of them into products.
- waterlesscloud 12y agoDoes the store get the money, or the government? I thought it was essentially a tax that's sent on to government coffers. EDIT- In Los Angeles county at least, the fee is retained by the stores 'to help with the cost of compliance'. Whatever that means.
- scotty79 12y agoSince this is USA then misreporting of the number of bags you used is most likely a felony punishable by prison if you're black. Recently I learned that you can get arrested when you switch subway cars, as it is a felony, not sure where, I guess NY. Perpetrator was black in that case.
- ThompJackie 12y agoI was wondering if they can apply the same concept to recyclable materials? Charge around 50 cents for each bottle extra, but then get refunded 50 cents when you recycle the bottle so it causes the customer to recycle more and if not, someone else will pick up the bottle themselves
- msherry 12y agoMost states in the USA do exactly this already.
- lbearl 12y agoFrom the sound of it, Michigan does it very well with their 10 cent deposit, and allowing most people to claim their deposit back right at the grocery store. California (with 5 cent CRV) is miserable with the places where we are supposed to claim our deposits being overrun with homeless and the places themselves not being all that great (I'm speaking from my experience in Orange County, YMMV).
- stonemetal 12y agoLess than a dozen states, nowhere near most.
- drivers99 12y agoOnly 11 states.[1] (That's more than I thought.) [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Container_deposit_legislation_in_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Container_deposit_legislation_i...
- pygy_ 12y agoThat's how beer and glass water bottles are handled in Belgium. It's been like this for at least 30 years, and it works fine.
- err4nt 12y agoI was just thinking about bottle deposits the other day. In places where they offer a bottle deposit and a refund when you return it do they consider those bottles your purchased property, or in those places do you just buy the drink and lease the bottle until it's returned? Is there an expectation of returning bottles in places that offer a refund, and does it affect your legal entitlement to the bottle in any way?
- err4nt 12y agoThey passed a bylaw here about ten years ago adding a 5¢ fee per bag 'for the environment' with the idea that the penance of paying for your bags was outweighed by the blessing your of donation, which was going counterbalance your minor environmental transgression and balance your eco-karma again. I don't mind paying for bags if I know the 5¢ is actually going to make an impact on the world I live in, but I fear that over the years every bag I've ever paid for has done nothing but pad the profits of a company already dedicated to destroying the environment I live in and instead offsets the 'eco-karma' cost to me.
- dublinben 12y agoWhy haven't you gotten reusable shopping bags in the ten years since that fee was instated? That's the purpose of these programs.
- pizza234 12y agoIt's not about eco-karma or mamacorps, and it's not actually a fee/tax. It simply prevents the fact that if you give something for free, people will waste it - it's a consumerist instinct. I've lived through both conditions and I found horrifying how people would take large amounts of bags, at stores, and napkins, at restaurants, just because they were free. Set a minimal fee, and clients will start to take just what they need, and no more (which paradoxically, is the opposite instict - not to waste money).
- freedom123 12y agoUnfortunately 5cents for a plastic bag has nothing to do with "working". The issue is coercion and nothing works when the gov forces private companies to comply with random rules. If you want private companies to encourage "bring your own bags" then you advocate that with free speech, not with the barrel of a gun. You can gather as much data you like about it "working" and however that will never matter because the entire project is the immoral and wrong.
- jpollock 12y agoOf course, all that's really happened is I've replaced the free plastic bags from the grocery store with non-free garbage bags from the same store. I still use the same amount of plastic.
- buckbova 12y agoGet it from amazon for 2 cents a bag and tell the bagger you'll use your own bags. http://www.amazon.com/T-Shirt-Carryout-Bags--Thank-Gracias/dp/B0025W9ALG http://www.amazon.com/T-Shirt-Carryout-Bags--Thank-Gracias/d...
- thomasahle 12y agoReally? I always find the garbage bags you buy use much less plastic than the thick carry grocery store ones.
- vinhboy 12y agoI like the plastic bag ban because cashiers and other shoppers don't look at me weird for NOT wanting a bag. Multiple times before the bag ban in my town, I would ask for no bags, because the item I bought is already tightly packaged. I would get the weirdest look from people... Maybe it was all in my head, but whatever, it works.
- nickmchardy 12y agoI get the same thing where I live. I use a plastic crate which not only means things don't fall over in the car boot, but it's also very quick to pack at the checkout.
- jrmg 12y agoYes - I think the fees work partially because they make it socially acceptable to bring your own bag. Even though the 'reason' people cite for bringing the bags is environmental responsibility, they didn't bring them before because their fear of being 'weird' stopped them. I may be projecting.
- megablast 12y ago> I like the plastic bag ban because cashiers and other shoppers don't look at me weird for NOT wanting a bag This has to be the most ridiculous concern to come out of all of this. If this is the worst thing to happen to you, congratulations.
- eli 12y agoWhen the bag tax was added in DC, cashiers stopped bagging items by default. I'd bet that a $0.01 tax would work nearly as well; I don't think it's about the money. To their credit, the city also apparently did a very good job of educating business owners and enforcing the tax. Compliance seems very high.
- chrismcb 12y agoWhat does the headline mean? What does "work" mean? More money for the store? An increased in illness as people use dirty bags? It would have been nice to indicate what this means at the beginning of the article.