3 ms·
This rationalization of essays is long in coming, because in truth the mythical status they're given is because they give students (and parents, and people sell
by patio11 17y ago
This rationalization of essays is long in coming, because in truth the mythical status they're given is because they give students (and parents, and people selling services to parents) the impression that even in late junior year something can be done to significantly increase their chances of admission into the university of their choice.
This is, largely, bunk: essays are weighted extremely modestly relative to grades, test scores, and race. For example, on the University of Michigan point system, where 100 points were needed for an admit, the difference between a 3.2 and 3.6 average was worth 8 points, the difference between a 21 and a 22 on the SAT was worth 4 points, the difference between black and white was worth 20 points, and the difference between the best essay they read every year and the worst was worth... 1 point.
http://www.umich.edu/~mrev/archives/1999/summer/chart.htm http://www.umich.edu/~mrev/archives/1999/summer/chart.htm
University of Michigan is distinguished from more selective universities more in that they had the misfortune to standardize and actually write down their admissions criteria rather than in having vastly different mixes than, e.g., MIT.