3 ms·
Fixing WP is simple. Edits should go through a formal draft->pink->red review cycle. Right now they go through a edit->immediate rejection cycle. By policy any
by bane 12y ago
Fixing WP is simple. Edits should go through a formal draft->pink->red review cycle. Right now they go through a edit->immediate rejection cycle.
By policy anybody should be able to submit draft edits, and these edits should hang around in a review queue for a large-ish group of reviewers to look them over and thumb-up, thumb-down them in a "pink" review. Any acceptance or rejection should require 3 or 4 thumbs up or down. If a thumbdown is given, the reviewer must state what's wrong with the edit (bad spelling/grammar/poor citation, whatever).
If the edit is ultimately rejected, the person who submitted it now has 3 or 4 pieces of feedback, hopefully one of them useful. Now they can fix the edit, resubmit and now it goes to the red review.
If the edit passes it goes to the red review.
Red review is the same, but if it passes it becomes "published" and the change is made. Red reviewers should be the top editors of WP. Because the pink review should filter out most of the crap, they'll hopefully be dealing with higher level stuff and their rejection rates should be lower. Only in cases where the edit somehow was really bad, should they reject it.
Now here's the other thing. If a red review results in a rejection, the submitter has to start over, but the editors that passed it in the pink review are penalized in some way. Perhaps a Karma system (e.g. to become a red reviewer, you must have pink reviewed correctly 500 edits or something, to become a pink reviewer you must have 200 edits succeed). Red reviewers with too high of a rejection/pass ratio may lose their editing powers as well in case some power-mad editor starts bulk deletionist policies.
This way people can both submit edits and be engaged as editors (so they can both see the crap that editors have to deal with and participate in improving WP at the meta-level).
Problem editors can also be flagged by contributors, an editor with some number of flags (say 10) by different submitters should be reviewed. After each review, the number of flags that will cause the next review should increase (maybe double or something). This will keep high quality editors in place and not waste time reviewing editor's work.
- niels_olson 12y agoThe new-page patrol seems like a reasonable place to add something like this https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:NewPagesFeed https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:NewPagesFeed
- jpatokal 12y agoYou've pretty much described "Flagged revisions" (1), which has been in testing since 2008 or thereabouts and has been adopted by a bunch of non-English Wikipedias, most notably German. Despite years of debate about the pros and cons, it has not been adopted on the English WP, although a very watered down version called "Pending changes" has been live since Dec 2012 (2). (1) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Flagged_revisions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Flagged_revisions (2) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:PC2012 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:PC2012
- bane 12y agoSo why isn't PC2012 the way of the world? An important feature of my proposal is also to hold reviewers accountable...a notable feature that's missing in the current WP world. (I'm sure there's some purposefully byzantine process to do so today, but hell if a casual contributor can figure it out).