4 ms·
I run a mediawiki based information site, and I disagree the following statement: >The software causes almost every problem that people complain about The rea
by grecy 12y ago
I run a mediawiki based information site, and I disagree the following statement:
>The software causes almost every problem that people complain about
The real problem is:
>As a result of the open nature of wiki editing, Wikipedia has built up an increasingly restrictive, massive, rule set of how to reject information
Wikipedia is not longer a place setup so people contribute information, it's a place set up to reject the addition of information (as you point out).
It's been a goal of my wiki to be the precise opposite, and it's been very interesting to see people go from "I hate wikis b/c of Wikipedia's stupid rules" to "huh, my edit was accepted" to "wow, this is extremely useful and collaborative".
I believe a wiki is not inherently bad, it's all the rejection rules they've built on top that are the problem.
- sparkzilla 12y agoHi, I checked your site out. It's a useful resource. However, it appears you are making it by yourself mainly. When you get a lot of users on your wiki you will have to make a lot of rules, or ban a lot of users. I used to run my site on MediaWiki too and moved to WordPress. I don't know if that would work for your content though.
- grecy 12y ago> When you get a lot of users on your wiki you will have to make a lot of rules, or ban a lot of users I'd like to hear your reasons why you think this will be needed? As long as the edit is something useful to traveling overland, it's allowed. That's the only rule, and I think it's the only rule that will ever be needed.
- sparkzilla 12y agoThe objective of any crowdsourcing system is to find people who know more about the topic than you. However, oftentimes those people are dicks. You need rules that will allow you to get their content without them causing you (or them) a lot of grief.