2 ms·
Yes, the buggy implementation is buggy in idealistic sense. But it doesn't matter. The fact is, that bug was de facto not visible until the OP introduced the mo
by acqq 12y ago
Yes, the buggy implementation is buggy in idealistic sense. But it doesn't matter. The fact is, that bug was de facto not visible until the OP introduced the more "clever" (shorter timeout) code. If the node were really, utterly problematic it wouldn't be on the internet.
What to do in this case? Well, what do you want to do? Want it to work with everything the same? You have to start with the timeout of 1s, like other TCP stacks do. That's what was tested, and then your behaviour to these nodes wouldn't be different from the rest of the internet. If you don't want to do this for all of yours connections (you're losing an advantage to the competitors), then be ready to introduce the list of nodes where you observe the behaviour, and assign the different starting timeout to them. Etc. There is always a solution, the wrong approach is "it can't be solved because it's against the RFC." The solution is making something work under the real-life limitations, and not having the world where there's no bad implementation (the state that's impossible to reach).
BTW I have an impression we don't understand each other because you have a "mathematical" approach (finding one counterexample, my theorem is disproved, let's wave my hand in the air in helplessness). I'm an engineer. There's a real life out there. Everything you can imagine will have a real life counterexample. Deal with it. Whatever you do, it's your decision. Ignore it, adapt, whatever, it depends on what you want to do. Just don't stay on "it's that others are wrong that's the problem, but I'm right and that's it." Unless you want to do this for show. But then allow me to claim it's just a show.
Imagine Google writing around 2000 "we won't index the badly formed HTML pages, because they are against the standard, and our XML processor will never work." There wouldn't be a Google today.