2 ms·
Isn't that a fairly arbitrary philosophical distinction? I'm not sure we can say which organism intends to distribute the resources, since that's a fairly anthr
by baddox 12y ago
Isn't that a fairly arbitrary philosophical distinction? I'm not sure we can say which organism intends to distribute the resources, since that's a fairly anthropocentric concept. I suppose one could ask whether the relationship between the large tree and the fungus is beneficial to the large tree despite the large tree losing some resources, but the answer seems to be yes.
- devindotcom 12y agoWell, if you look at it from the ecosystem's standpoint, it's just a check or balance. But the fungus is, like pretty much all life, acting in its own self-interest. The trees don't even have to "consent" to this — it seems that it's more likely that a fungus is acting as a sort of benevolent parasite than that very different trees have established some kind of cross-platform messaging system that uses a third, very different type of organism as a mediator. It's just simpler to me to think that the fungus is acting on its own and it ends up being a net gain for everyone involved.
- schiffern 12y ago>The trees don't even have to "consent" to this The trees benefit as well — the fungus gives minerals, and in exchange the trees give sugars. It's a transaction. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mycorrhiza#Sugar-water.2Fmineral_exchange https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mycorrhiza#Sugar-water.2Fminer... >benevolent parasite The word you're looking for is "symbiosis". It seems like you're trying hard to view this through a lens of competition instead of cooperation.
- devindotcom 12y agoI'm aware of the word, I chose to say something different. Why is competition a "lens" I must see through?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- emmelaich 12y ago(Speaking of anthropocentrism) The day before I saw this story I remarked to my kids that trees can think. It's just very slow - might take 20 years to form a thought. I'm still not sure how serious I was but it makes you wonder about where and how many qualitatively different levels of "thinking" there are between trees, dogs and us.