3 ms·
Wow, I didn't even read the questions on the chart; I just assumed it was the same. Yeah, that is very different than what I saw. > many libertarian ideas need
by wpietri 12y ago
Wow, I didn't even read the questions on the chart; I just assumed it was the same. Yeah, that is very different than what I saw.
> many libertarian ideas need to come in duplets or triplets
Yes, that makes a lot of sense to me. I think markets are really neat mechanisms for balancing outcomes, but they require certain conditions to work.
I also think there's a certain kind of ignoring-air-resistance theme common to a lot of the sort of Libertarianism I find dangerous. E.g., the "let people vote with their dollars" thing. It can work reasonably well for issues where people have enough time and attention to devote, where the results of their choices are relatively clear, and where people get to make choices frequently enough to build up a body of knowledge. But all that subtlety gets discarded, with arguments seeming to come from an assumption of perfect information, perfect rationality, and infinite processing power.
It all feels very fundamentalist to me. Of course, a positive feedback loop like you describe, one that radicalizes, would head toward fundamentalism.
- ep103 12y agoyeah, exactly. Just like in the carbon emissions example, let the people vote with their dollars only makes sense if there is governmental regulation ensuring the people both get accurate information to make decisions, are educated to understand the decision, and that the people's market decisions will be large enough to steer the market. All three of these points are regularly ignored, however, while the first "let the people vote with their dollars", will be loudly trumpeted by whatever industry is being discussed. Over time, you get a "libertarian" population that isn't even aware that their position requires the regulations I just mentioned, but have been taught that regulations are "bad" by industry. Its a bit like watching a group petition Ford motors to make an electric car, but one without any batteries because batteries are dangerous and expensive, and then get confused and upset with Ford's "corruption" and the "inability of corporations to do anything right" when Ford makes them an "electric" car with a gasoline engine.