3 ms·
> Let me tell you a story. We only had five Fellows in our first class at Code2040, but they were amazing. We had one Fellow who had a 4.7 out of a 5.0 GPA, was
by TulliusCicero 12y ago
> Let me tell you a story. We only had five Fellows in our first class at Code2040, but they were amazing. We had one Fellow who had a 4.7 out of a 5.0 GPA, was copresident of his school, varsity athlete at MIT. They went through the program and excelled. But when they interviewed at larger companies, they had to do these "whiteboard" interviews, where you're given a coding challenge and you go to the whiteboard and attack it. And our guys didn't get hired, right? They had never done a whiteboard interview. So, in that case, is there something wrong with the fellow, or is there something wrong with the interview process? Folks need to really understand what implicit biases they have. Until they do, the numbers aren't gonna change.
Is he implying that the interview was biased because the coding camp didn't teach people about whiteboard interviews?
- itchyouch 12y agoEssentially. This is part of a culture pass he speaks about. If he were really exposed to the tech community, he would realize that whiteboard interviews tend to be pretty widespread.
- yongjik 12y agoErm, I'm not so sure about that. When I applied to Google the recruiter literally explained there will be whiteboard interviews. She even recommended a book about preparing for software interviews. (I think I read about half of the book.) It can be daunting if you never expected it, but whiteboard interviews are ubiquitous: you should be prepared except perhaps for your very first such interview. (And it shouldn't take more than two weeks or so. Just re-read the first half of, say, CLRS (or any algorithm textbook you should have studied before), and try solving a few of the problems on the whiteboard.)
- humanrebar 12y agoI think he's fairly explicitly stating that whiteboard reviews are probably bogus. I don't think that's too controversial of a position to hold these days. I think he's also saying that whiteboard interviews probably disadvantage people from atypical backgrounds. I think that's probable. I've seen people with good resumes struggle in whiteboard interviews due to what I guess are communication and confidence issues.
- gatehouse 12y agoThat makes sense to me, interview problems are highly synthetic and most people will probably need to prep specifically for the common tech interview process. If you don't have access to people who are interviewing regularly then it would be easy not to fully grasp how important this type of thing is to your earning power, given the lack of importance to your job performance.
- TulliusCicero 12y ago> I think he's fairly explicitly stating that whiteboard reviews are probably bogus. I don't think that's too controversial of a position to hold these days. There has been a lot of criticism of whiteboard interviews, but they're still used because nobody has come up with a good alternative. Larger "take-home" programming assignments are vulnerable to cheating, and "Work with us for a week" only works for people who either freelance or are unemployed. I also wouldn't say that they're "bogus". Flawed, certainly.
- gohrt 12y agoThat's a pretty poor coding camp that doesn't prepare students for the decades-old standard interview process.
- kelukelugames 12y agoAs an MIT grad this example sounds like horseshit. 1. 4.7 out of 5.0 = 3.7 out of 4.0, which isn't really something to flaunt. 2. MIT has amazing career prep. I imagine a lot of schools do. There is no way a candidate got blindsided by whiteboard questions.