3 ms·
No, I think the difference between nazi and coumminst terror is not just historical perception. There is a very clear difference between political terror and ra
by fauigerzigerk 17y ago
No, I think the difference between nazi and coumminst terror is not just historical perception. There is a very clear difference between political terror and racism. You can choose to be a communist or not. You can choose to be politically active or not. You cannot choose whether you are jewish or not.
The communists killed political opponents and they killed many more people by plain incompetence. They did not set up an industrial operation to deliberately murder people _regardless_ of what they did.
It's not just a numbers game either. If it were, the inventor of the automobile would have to be considered one of the greatest villains in the history of mankind. So we do make a difference based on the motivation for killing people. Here's my hierachy of evil, which explains why I agree with those who find communism less horrible than the nazi holocaust:
Killing people for what they are
Killing people for what they do
Killing people by accident or incompetence
Letting people die unnecessarily
The nazis did all four. The communists just the latter three. Capitalism specialises in the the last item. And yes there are exceptions that blur the lines (like Stalinist ethnic cleansing), but they are just that, exceptions.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- unalone 17y agoGood points, but: There are many genocides that target based on race or religion. So I was trying to explain why the Holocaust and not a similar genocide targeting, say, racial groups.
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoYes there are many. But I'm not aware of one that was as elaborate, ideologically and logistically, as what the nazis did. In my opinion they fully deserve their place at the top of the evil list.