3 ms·
> Some comments degrade the quality of the conversation. We might disagree about which ones, but surely we can agree about that, right? Yes. > I don't underst
by peterwwillis 12y ago
> Some comments degrade the quality of the conversation. We might disagree about which ones, but surely we can agree about that, right?
Yes.
> I don't understand what this means or what a "meritocracy" is in this setting.
Basically, thread sorting would be based (mostly) on merit.
> the highest ranked users will never form a ruling class or be in power
The highest ranking users have high social power. Their power is simply a tendency to steer the group without telling anyone what to do. Usually it's unintentional, and sometimes they have no idea they're doing.
Most forums are actually discrete social communities made up of ingroups, with their own cultural standards and hierarchies, and often a few custom heuristics. Some of them are really incredible from a behavioral standpoint, like an internet chat galapagos island. HN is not so special, but it does have a clearly defined social structure.
I agree with you that the stupid jokes, memes etc should stay off HN. That's why I think some kind of meta-voting is necessary: because a simple downvote is used for a lot of things right now, and not just "this-comment-is-out-of-bounds" like you're talking about. Barring meta-voting, removing the downvote keeps the troll talk but it still filters down to the bottom with the other useless comments.