4 ms·
Anecdotes are not data.
by bane 12y ago
Anecdotes are not data.
- spacemanmatt 12y agoIf you want proof, do your own sociology homework. I think the burden rests on you, to show most assaults on LEOs are not trumped up bullshit, in this case. Cops lie.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- DSMan195276 12y agoI don't see how you can claim the burden falls on him. They already presented a study saying how many assaults happen on cops per year, if you want to refute that study with evidence then that's your burden - It's not their job to form your arguments for you just because you think you're right.
- bane 12y agoThe burden of proof doesn't fall on me, I didn't make the claim.
- coldtea 12y agoYou seem to require no proof from those making the statistics though. Is it because police and official documents have been historically proven inherently trustworthy?
- coldtea 12y agoYou'd be surprised. Data are just collections of anecdotes. Everything in the end goes down to trust, if you trust official statements then you probably haven't read enough history. There are anecdotes that are more accurate and trustworthy than "data" on the same subject. For example, would you believe the official "annual report on poverty rates" by the government of South Korea? Or would you believe a person who lived there and is recounting the conditions? I wouldn't believe official records of police "assaults" that the police has compiled itself either. Like I wouldn't believe official records that show how police was totally "racially blind" in Missouri, etc. I find this obsession with data on non hard-science issues, especially social issues, idiotic and mechanical. If anything it obstructs with getting to the truth of things. Here are how some of the official responses (that people esteemed as "data") turned out: http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/almost-everything-in-dr-strangelove-was-true http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/almost-everything-in...
- bane 12y ago> Data are just collections of anecdotes. No, actually they aren't. Pretty much the rest of anything you can say on the matter, and anything about how you view the world is invalidated by that simple belief. You see, the problem is that you've decided to build a world view off of unfalsifiable beliefs, not fact. You pretend to sound like you're questioning the veracity of facts, which is normally a reasonable thing to do, but what you're actually doing is preventing anything from shaking the preconceived notion that you've decided to glom onto. It's simply a ceremony you follow to help reinforce your beliefs. When you enter into a "debate" like this one, you aren't there to change people's minds, or have your mind changed, your simply shoving the iron bar of your belief system down everybody else's throat and see if you stir up sympathetic ears to help continue to justify what you want to see in the world. When you can't find support for your notions, you rely on semantically connected, but otherwise nonsequitur references, a classic redirection technique. The issue that started all this is "was Aaron treated well in police custody", some people were shocked at what the inside of a police station looks like, but Aaron was treated just fine. Meanwhile you're off in Denmark and South Korea talking about poverty and experimental Danish maximum security prisons. They both involve "the man" so they must be relevant to the discussion, no? No. They aren't.