3 ms·
The food you have in your plate is coming from "bullshit jobs", you know ?
by ekianjo 12y ago
The food you have in your plate is coming from "bullshit jobs", you know ?
- rjtavares 12y agoWe need a name for the "bullshit job provides food on your plate" fallacy. The productivity enhancement from the division of labor and technological advancements provides food on our table, the "bullshit job" is just there because we haven't figure out how to destroy it without hurting people.
- ekianjo 12y agoNo, read again what I wrote. The food you get is coming from people who do bullshit jobs, since Farming is probably bullshit in the eyes of the poster I referred to. If you want to start destroying bullshit jobs, reducing the amount of administration and civil servants is a good place to start, because it's a whole additional layer of friction for everything else in society.
- polymatter 12y agoI believe he is using the term "bullshit jobs" to mean jobs that are pointless, produce no producivity and are mainly created for the sake of appearances. In other words, the administration and civil servant jobs that you refer to. Jobs such as farm laborer jobs may be boring and tedious, but since they are very clearly productive, are not "bullshit jobs". This term comes from the anthoropologist David Graeber in his essay 'On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs' (http://strikemag.org/bullshit-jobs/ http://strikemag.org/bullshit-jobs/).
- partition 12y agoI can't believe that fallacy got around. It's oxymoronic, it is just like the sentence "non-swimming fish moves around in your filled aquarium."
- partition 12y agoOk, you are literally equating food production, which includes agriculture which led to humans being able to support groups bigger than a circus troupe, with "bullshit job." Got it.
- ekianjo 12y agoYeah, the job description of food production fits nicely with the post about bullshits jobs from a couple of days ago. I am assuming you are using the same definition here. EDIT: on top of that, you could argue that Agriculture is bullshit since most of the food we produce is thrown away?
- partition 12y agoNice assumptions dude. I guess this is the internet for ya; post something that is not even very controversial, and your own caricatured projection is jumped on. On your other note, it is not bullshit as long as it is sustainable and people are being fed. If it was, you bet it'd be fixed, one way or the other, up to, including, and beyond cannibalism to genetic re-engineering not to need food. On the other hand, there is your typical TechCrunch startup lol. Don't even bother replying. It seems we are so different in how in touch we are, I could be locked in an internetless and lightless room with no outside communication for the rest of my life, and still be able to do non bullshit work, which I'd scratch into the walls with my fingernails, so when I die and they open the box to take me out they (at least the in-touch ones) will be awed and the world will be a better place, while you could be handed the US presidency, or the leadership of a multi-national corporation, and still cock it up by starving the population and workers to death by removing "bullshit jobs" lol.
- SnacksOnAPlane 12y agoI think you misread the comment. Agriculture is not a "bullshit job" (well, except in the literal manure = fertilizer sense) because it produces something people actually need. Something like, say, social marketing (my job) is a bullshit job, because it's just made up to encourage people to consume more to keep the economy humming along.