5 ms·
> Seeing Aaron made to stand shoeless, handcuffed to a metal bar for over 23 minutes as armed men rifled through his belongings and occasionally asked him quest
by bhouston 12y ago
> Seeing Aaron made to stand shoeless, handcuffed to a metal bar for over 23 minutes as armed men rifled through his belongings and occasionally asked him questions, I can't help but think this process is designed to be demeaning.
This likely happens dozens of times a day across the US and Canada. I think this is to be expected when you encounter law enforcement in this situation.
- coldtea 12y ago>This likely happens dozens of times a day across the US and Canada. I think this is to be expected when you encounter law enforcement in this situation. To "be expected" stasticially, based on experience of how those things happen, yes. But not "to be expected" as "par for the course". No civilized citizenry should accept that thing.
- bane 12y agoWhy don't you outline how you think a typical booking should go for a person under arrest for B&E? You appear to have strong feelings on the subject, you keep raising how other countries do it. Bring your international expertise into the picture and outline how you must know they do a similar procedure in say: Ireland, Spain, France, Germany, Italy, Thailand, South Korea, China and England? Please highlight where those systems provide a particularly good experience for the suspect and where they need work. Compare and contrast to the booking procedures in a typical American police station. Maybe do it as a series of blog posts, with diagrams, furniture photos and fabric selections?
- coldtea 12y ago>Why don't you outline how you think a typical booking should go for a person under arrest for B&E? You appear to have strong feelings on the subject, you keep raising how other countries do it. Bring your international expertise into the picture and outline how you must know they do a similar procedure in say: Ireland, Spain, France, Germany, Italy, Thailand, South Korea, China and England? Calmly and professinally. I've witnessed arrests in at least 2 of those places (and in general in England, France, Amsterdam (Holland) and Denmark). Not even comparable to things we see in the US. Here are some examples: 1) People CAN and DO get out of their cars when a policeman stops them. They don't stay inside until he approaches out of fear they'll get shot as violent criminals no questions asked. 2) The British police don't even carry guns. 3) Tasering is something that simply almost never happens. Not something the police would use for the first wino or homeless person out in the street. 4) For most simple arrests you are not tied anywhere. You are just taken to the station were they verify your identity and/or temporarily hold you in a holding cell with others. Plus, you keep mentioning B&E. Most cops are able to tell B&E with assault weapons by some thugs in a house from a nerd getting into a university lab for hacking, and treat each case accordingly.
- bane 12y agoa) spent most of your reply talking about non-sequitur topics again. Here's a pony. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/6/6a/Shetland_Pony_on_Belstone_Common,_Dartmoor.jpg/1280px-Shetland_Pony_on_Belstone_Common,_Dartmoor.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/6/6a/Sh... b) #4 that's not true everywhere, even in the U.S. c) didn't answer the question. How should it work? d) "Most cops are able to tell B&E with assault weapons by some thugs in a house from a nerd getting into a university lab for hacking, and treat each case accordingly." That's what it looks like to me. They didn't have a group of cops there to subdue Aaron in case he got wild, or any other escalation procedure. They made him "mildly uncomfortable" at best. If standing in one place for half an hour is some kind of dehumanizing terrible treatment, then the DMV should be on trial for war crimes. Look, I get it, you don't like the police at all. You get all kinds of bent out of shape whenever they do any minor part of their job except greet you. But you're attempting to draw a fantasy picture here that simply doesn't exist. The simple fact of the matter is, sometimes things go smoothly, sometimes the police have to tussle. They optimize for the tussle. That's why you see half a dozen police subduing a taxi driver in London during a protest, or Garda blocking in an ongoing arrest with cars. It only takes a guy throwing a chair during his booking a couple times before future suspects are put behind glass. Only idiots invite harm. The police may be brutes, but they aren't stupid.
- coldtea 12y ago>Look, I get it, you don't like the police at all. You get all kinds of bent out of shape whenever they do any minor part of their job except greet you. No, I get it, you are an American, and are conditioned to have the police treat you like a criminal even when not convinced of anything. You might even think it's OK how the treat black people in the streets, because after all "so many blacks are criminals, how would they know". Under those conditions bending over is understandble.
- psycr 12y agoDozens? Thousands of times a day, surely - if not tends of thousands. There are nearly 400 million people between the two countries. Regardless, yes, this is to be expected. But reality isn't normative - it just is. The question is, ought it be that way.
- maerF0x0 12y agoalso, we can't confound "normative" with "moral" .
- simplemath 12y agoshouldn't? yes. Can't? Unfortunately, no.
- maerF0x0 12y agohaha, nice.
- borski 12y agoThe answer is, I believe, yes. The booking officer had no idea why Aaron was there, for a while, and later discovered it was for B&E, a serious crime. The entire time, the officers' job is to protect themselves and their fellow officers. If Aaron had been a worse kid, and they had been less extensive, it is possible one of them may have been hurt. This is unpopular, but I believe it to be true, I think. Aaron was a great kid, but the majority of people brought into the station aren't.
- vdaniuk 12y ago> The entire time, the officers' job is to protect themselves and their fellow officers. >This is unpopular, but I believe it to be true, I think. Your belief is simply wrong. The risk of dying in a line of duty for cops is quite low, being a LE is not even in the first top 10 dangerous professions. Most deaths are due to the traffic incidents.[0] >Aaron was a great kid, but the majority of people brought into the station aren't. Who defines that? Police? Nice circular logic you've got there. Until the court says otherwise they are citizens whose rights should be upheld as much as possible. Also it's great that US has such upstanding citizens as you, protecting the real opressed minority - policemen. If Aaron would be wearing his shoes, who knows what grave harm could he do to a police station full of armed cops? EDIT I digged a little deeper and found out that number of police deaths in the line of duty during latest years had been around 100/year[1]. At least 1450 were people killed by police since May 2013[2]. I don't wish that on you but there would be a certain ironical justice if police apologists like you would experience non-lethal brutality themeselves. Maybe then you would learn something. [0]http://www.theagitator.com/2007/12/28/how-dangerous-is-police-work/ http://www.theagitator.com/2007/12/28/how-dangerous-is-polic... [1]http://www.nleomf.org/facts/officer-fatalities-data/year.html http://www.nleomf.org/facts/officer-fatalities-data/year.htm... [2]http://fivethirtyeight.com/datalab/another-much-higher-count-of-police-homicides/ http://fivethirtyeight.com/datalab/another-much-higher-count...