2 ms·
The critical part of this strategy is continuous improvement I'm not sure that's true. The occasional sweep to clear away the deadwood is one thing. But if I t
by gaius 17y ago
The critical part of this strategy is continuous improvement
I'm not sure that's true. The occasional sweep to clear away the deadwood is one thing. But if I think about the team I'm in right now, it took a long time (years) to build, we are very very picky about who we let in, and it takes a considerable amount of time to get someone up to speed (regardless of the experience they had when coming in).
If the edict came down from on-high that we had to fire the least-performing member and hire someone new every year, well, we simply can't find people at the required level and train them to our own standard that quickly. It would simply destroy a high-performing team for the sake of some fad.
Also, deciding the bottom 10% is not always as straightforward as it seems. Say HR simply sacks the guy who shipped the least features that quarter and the team loses the guru who helped everyone else with their tricky problems?
- andymism 17y agoAlso, deciding the bottom 10% is not always as straightforward as it seems. That's exactly right and the biggest problem with a rank and fire policy is that there are so many pitfalls in quantitatively judging relative performance. In the case of a high performing or highly specialized group, the question comes down to who does the measuring and how much power would she have to say letting someone go isn't necessary. I'm just speculating, but my guess is that the powers up high at Enron wouldn't have let that slide. We should also remember that this article was published just 6 months before Enron filed bankruptcy. While ranking and fire sounds sane in principle, we have to wonder how much this sort of hire-fast-fire-fast policy contributed to the systemic and ethical break downs that have made the company infamous.