16 ms·
> I can't be the only one that thinks it's ridiculous for a prison to accommodate voluntary diets like this. Well, it all depends on whether you think a prison
by r00fus 12y ago
> I can't be the only one that thinks it's ridiculous for a prison to accommodate voluntary diets like this.
Well, it all depends on whether you think a prison is meant primarily for rehabilitation or punishment.
- paulhauggis 12y agoon HN, it depends. a greedy corporate fat cat that cheated people? punishment. Drug or copyright infringement related crimes? rehab.
- angersock 12y agoIt would help all of us, I imagine, were we to actually use separate institutions for those purposes.
- crazypyro 12y agoAre you implying that the distinction the grandparent poster made is correct? (I'm almost positive it was sarcastic) All prisons should be about rehabilitation. Anything else is simply a multiplier to an already existent drain on society.
- jackvalentine 12y agoAnd why so you think that is? (I'm withholding my opinion/explanation until I feel I understand yours and can provide a more valuable response)
- ChuckMcM 12y agoI don't know paul, and his comment reads like a counter-troll, but the implicit statement that the audience of the statement incorporates their own perspective on the morality of the crime into their perception of the remedy is valid. The question about diets for prisoners that accommodate the needs of the prisoner is generally a 20th century concept[1]. And generally case after case has sided with the prisoners[2]. [1] I've yet to find a case prior to the treatment of prisoners of war in WW 1 that discussed diet but I haven't looked particularly hard so I offer this opinion with confidence but not certainty :-) [2] Recent example -- https://www.prisonlegalnews.org/news/2014/may/19/florida-prison-system-ordered-provide-kosher-meals/ https://www.prisonlegalnews.org/news/2014/may/19/florida-pri...
- tedunangst 12y agoThe things I want to do shouldn't be crimes. The things I don't like other people doing should be crimes.
- baddox 12y agoWhen you say "punishment," are you also including the deterrent effect of the threat of punishment?
- baddox 12y agoWhy does it depend on that?
- Someone1234 12y agoBecause the only goal of forcing someone to eat something they consider immoral is to punish. It certainly won't help rehabilitation efforts (likely hurt them, in fact).
- baddox 12y agoThat need not be a goal, and it certainly wouldn't be the only goal. The primary goal would be cost and logistics. I don't think prisons have chefs custom making meals for each prisoner.
- Someone1234 12y agoShort term savings for long term costs. How much is recidivism costing the US right now? They have made massive savings per prisoner but their reoffending rates are 60% Vs. 30% for Sweden.
- tedunangst 12y agoAnd you think recidivism in the US is based on the food? Prison food is so good people can't wait to commit more crimes and get back inside?
- na85 12y agoOh please. Parent post argues that forcing inmates to eat food they consider immoral contributes to their "fuck the Man" mentality, and contributes to the recidivist mentality. By spinning that into an argument about prison food being so good as to attract reoffenders, you are being childish and dishonest.
- Alupis 12y agoI seriously doubt quality of food is a factor in reoffending rates.