4 ms·
Why do you assume that Libertarians are pro-net neutrality? It's government regulation that limits what ISPs can do - hardly a free market philosophy.
by untog 12y ago
Why do you assume that Libertarians are pro-net neutrality? It's government regulation that limits what ISPs can do - hardly a free market philosophy.
- LyndsySimon 12y ago+1. I'm a libertarian, and I'm not necessarily pro-NN.
- baldfat 12y agoSo you are for Government to change the Internet by making rules that only help a localized Monopoly? I don't get how people don't see that this is a monopoly based on Government intervention???? Started with cable TV and now we are stuck with this in internet monopolies which are 100% anti-free market.
- LyndsySimon 12y agoI have no idea how you drew that conclusion from my post.
- ende 12y agoAccording to who? Common carrier is precisely the kind of regulation that free market grandfather Adam Smith supported in his writings. Land-based broadband ISPs do not currently exist in a competetive market, and likely cannot due to issues of redundancy in physical infrastructures. Common carrier regulation is an attempt to limit the effects of such monopoly power. It may be 'two wrongs making a right', but suggest an alternative.
- mhluongo 12y agoPro-neutrality libertarian here. I used to think my philosophy precluded net neutrality, then I looked into how these companies became entrenched- and it was by government support. Live by the sword, die by the sword.
- fche 12y agotwo wrongs don't make a right
- webXL 12y agoExactly. It's what happened with banks. The government passes regulation after regulation, and pretty soon it's hard to tell the difference between the bankers and the regulators except for what kind of car they drive (now), and gets harder for new competition to enter the market, so banks consolidate and eventually become too big to fail, leading to obscene profits for very little risk. Entrenched market players LOVE, LOVE, LOVE more regulation. All they have to do is hire more compliance officers and pass the cost on to us, while at the same time raising the cost of compliance for smaller and would-be competition.
- mhluongo 12y agoCatchy, but inappropriate. If there were a free market way to reset the playing field, I'd certainly prefer that. But I've yet to hear one, and crony capitalists are a problem as much as statists.
- randyrand 12y ago"Mr. Milton, how much government intervention is required to deal with monopolies and..." https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tdLBzfFGFQU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tdLBzfFGFQU