5 ms·
You can have my Humanity Card, because that's a complete load of crap. You don't need to always drive yourself to misery wanting what you don't have, especiall
by eli_gottlieb 12y ago
You can have my Humanity Card, because that's a complete load of crap. You don't need to always drive yourself to misery wanting what you don't have, especially because, if you know you're not going to enjoy it when you get it, you can simply stop wanting it.
Bloody hell, give me three months of vacation time to spend at the beach and I can make a solid start on coming up with an ideal way to spend the rest of my life. It's just a matter of resources.
- pron 12y agoYou completely misunderstood me. I'm not saying that you always drive yourself to misery wanting what you don't have, just that human happiness is often a very complicated thing, and not one that should be viewed first through the SV prism of "optimization". > if you know you're not going to enjoy it when you get it, you can simply stop wanting it. Actually, Daniel Kahneman has spent the last few decades showing that that's exactly what people do: they want something that they know will make them happy, but once they get it, it doesn't make them as happy as they thought, and they want something else[1]. It is called the focusing illusion and Kahneman summarizes it as "nothing in life is as important as you think it is when you are thinking about it." Stupid, I know, but that's how our particular species of apes actually behaves, and this is a lot more rooted in reality than optimizing happiness. Aside from the focusing illusion, Kahneman demonstrates that people's tastes change over time, and you might not even want what you want now by the time you get it. Again, this all simply shows that human happiness is complicated; not that anyone knows exactly how it works. [1]: http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/ambigamy/201204/nobel-prize-winner-weighs-in-don-t-worry-be-happy http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/ambigamy/201204/nobel-pr...
- calinet6 12y agoYou're optimizing the wrong thing if you're looking outside of the human mind. Change the behavior surrounding our desires and happiness and you solve many of these problems. You might say changing the way our minds work is very difficult, but surely it's easier than attempting to create an impossible utopia.
- pron 12y agoBut then we'd no longer be human...
- calinet6 12y agoAn extremely common misconception. Human nature does not mean that our behavior is permanent, set in stone, fixed. Our biological bugs are not our humanity, nor are our biological advantages. We are quite greater than our biology, and we've proven again and again that we are capable of improving upon it. I'll just throw the whole institution of "education" out there as an example.
- pron 12y agoWell, that's a deep philosophical question of whether there's an essence to humanity. But I think that if by some miracle we can turn humans into rational beings, then our entire set of motivations, aspirations and drives will change. Education does not do that. So far, over the course of history, we have not changed any of what people may call "our nature".
- calinet6 12y agoWe have turned humans, largely, into much more rational beings than they were in the past. Education and progress does do that, most clearly. There is always human nature, but in the most educated societies, you see a completely different behavioral state.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoWe have trained people to behave in a mode that appears rational, when examined from the framework of their culture. But that's always been true - even prehistoric people survived according to how well adapted their myths and behaviors were to their environment.
- pron 12y agoI think most historians would disagree with you. Actually, there's one quite famous study that touches on this topic, The Civilizing Process[1] by Norbert Elias. It is a fascinating work, but debated by most historians. One interesting subtopic there is the internalization of the feeling of disgust. Elias shows how disgust -- which we often experience physiologically -- is a social construct that evolved through the ages. Other than that, it is well accepted that some societies have built large, faceless institutions, and evolved from a face-to-face society to a society of strangers. It is a profound change, but no one claims that such a society is more rational than a face-to-face, let alone its members. The behavioral state you're referring to is largely accepted to be nothing more than social norms in a society of strangers. [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Civilizing_Process http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Civilizing_Process