4 ms·
Walmart's Mike Cook asks an interesting question; At a physical store, if you use any other mobile app, like LevelUp, then the merchant pays the higher 'card-n
by zaroth 12y ago
Walmart's Mike Cook asks an interesting question;
At a physical store, if you use any other mobile app, like LevelUp, then the merchant pays the higher 'card-not-present' rate. The same transaction with Apple Pay pays the lower 'card-present' rate. But an in-app purchase on an iPhone still charges the 'card-not-present' rate.
Visa's Jim McCarty's response is, "Fundamentally because the payload is different. One is a full EMV track read transaction and the other is not."
"Because it's a rule that y'all made?"
"No, because the data doesn't flow. It's why the standard was written like that." ... and then later Jim quips... "That's the first time Mike's complained about getting the card-present rate." which the moderator replies "OK, that gets the best answer beer."
The format of the packet is irrelevant. The security properties are derived from the user interaction points. Specifically, Alice loads her card into Apple Pay by taking a picture of it. A week later Alice uses her phone to pay with Apple Pay and the merchant would get a card-present rate. Can any other app do the same thing? Is there an open standard which allows LevelUp (who currently is forced to pay card-not-present) to use the same exact steps and get the same favorable rate? If not, I think Cook has a very valid point.
Apple Pay wins by default if they are the only mobile app in town which can get a card-present rate. I assume Google Wallet is card-not-present, for example. Merchants won't pay a higher rate so you can use some app. Jim McCarty specifically mentions the scale problem with changing brick & mortar merchants card-not-present rates.
- fpgeek 12y agoAccording to this: http://www.quora.com/Is-Google-Wallet-considered-a-card-present-or-card-not-present-transaction http://www.quora.com/Is-Google-Wallet-considered-a-card-pres... Google Wallet is card-present for the merchant, but card-not-present between Google and the consumer. I guess that means Google is eating the difference between the two rates (and/or has other tricks up their sleeve).
- demallien 12y agoI would imagine that it is because brick and mortar merchants are a lower fraud risk than an online property. Don't forget that visa and MasterCard suck up fraud on both sides of the transaction. Which is not to say that there aren't shenanigans going on, but there's a reason that consumers really like MasterCard and visa, they both look after customer interests, sometimes at the expense of merchants.
- tomp 12y agoWhat kind of fraud is there to suck up at the merchant part of the transaction? Isn't it so that if the merchant doesn't deliver, they don't get paid?
- gambiting 12y agoIn the EU, merchants have to pay for swipe card fraud. Let's say you buy something with a swipe card, scribble a signature on the receipt, then ring your bank few hours later saying that there is a transaction you don't recognize. Then your bank requests the receipt from the merchant, the signatures don't match = you get reimbursed full amount, the merchant has no money and no goods - because in EU it is the merchant's responsibility to check if the signatures match. If they don't, they didn't do their job properly, therefore they have to pay. This is the reason why pretty much nobody accepts swipe cards in EU anymore - there's very few places which even have swipe terminals, it's all chip and pin. The couple times when my chip didn't work, the cashier had to key in the number of the card manually, because she didn't have a swipe terminal at the till.
- netcan 12y agoMasterCard and Visa have the ability to put the full cost of fraud (including a fee for dealing with it) onto merchants in many/most cases. This includes "friendly fraud" of the false chargeback variety (customer falsely claims they did not receive a product) taking advantage of consumer protection guarantees offered by MasterCard and Visa to their customers as a value add. IE, CC companies offer their customers consumer protection to encourage use of their product. They charge merchants when a consumer uses the product. Then, they unload the risks, costs and other burdens inherent in offering this add on service onto merchants as well. This is why they put little effort into investigating claims, making it feasible for merchants to dispute them or otherwise preventing fraudulent claims. It's has a distinct odor of oligopoly. Oligopoly also allows for price setting. IE, the forces pushing the cost of a good or service closer to the (marginal) cost of producing it are weak. It could also be that "card present" is cheaper because in-store purchases have to compete with cash purchases. IE, they might be charging the higher fees because they can, not because they have to.
- Shivetya 12y agoApple Pay is like iBook to me. Apple making these grandiose claims about how much they are doing this for us. Yet there is this issue of Apple taking a cut while binding us the very credit card companies many of us find repugnant. I know, but its Apple!!! Well Apple condom or not, its still the same in the end, they sell us to the CC companies and we are supposed to be happy. Check with my credit union, no plans though a CC I do have elsewhere does offer it. As far as stores, I can see the issue with being bound to the higher payment structure CC require (in or out) compared to options they are developing as a group. I am not too pleased with privacy issues of their idea but its not like I appreciate my CC's privacy issues either
- aaronem 12y agoIt's been some decades since the only option for a payment card was a line of revolving credit. You can get one that's tied to a deposit account, no chattel-slavery strings attached, and they sure are handy things to have. (I don't love revolving credit any more than the next guy -- less, in fact; I've worked in the industry and seen its unloveliness firsthand. But you can get the benefit of a payment card without it.)
- aaronem 12y ago> One is a full EMV track read transaction and the other is not. I don't see how that can be true; loading a card into Apple Pay is done via photo or manually, neither of which entails a swipe of the card through something like a Square reader, which is what would be necessary for Apple Pay to provide "full EMV track read" data. The information available via Apple Pay is therefore necessarily a proper subset of that encoded into the magstripe, which, according to the Visa rep's statement, should require that Apple Pay transactions be billed under the same card-not-present fee scheme as in-app purchases and online transactions. Your argument from packet format is irrelevant; "user interaction points" don't enter into it, under the rules defined and promulgated by the card associations. Those rules include a distinction between card-present and card-not-present transactions, made on the basis of whether or not the transaction data includes a full and valid magstripe read. Apple Pay transactions cannot include such a read, because, based on the methods by which a card can be enrolled in Apple Pay by its user, the information available at transaction time cannot be other than a proper subset of what a magstripe read would provide. It's understandable that WalMart's Cook should be cross over this; his irritation stems from the perception that "the fix is in" between Apple and the card associations, such that they're breaking their own rules to give preferential treatment to Apple Pay. On the other hand, these are their rules; the conditions under which various transaction fee schemes apply are defined entirely by the card associations (Visa and MasterCard, et al.), and if they want to extend preferential treatment in this fashion, then it's entirely within their scope to do so. In effect, the rule for a card-present transaction has been extended with a clause "...or if it's done by Apple Pay". This is a special case of a more general rule under which effectively all card association operations occur, and whose most concise formulation is "Because we say so."
- wfjackson 12y ago>On the other hand, these are their rules; the conditions under which various transaction fee schemes apply are defined entirely by the card associations (Visa and MasterCard, et al.), and if they want to extend preferential treatment in this fashion, then it's entirely within their scope to do so. And how is what Walmart accepts for payment in their own stores is not under Walmart's own scope?