4 ms·
Don't blame the parties. The parties react quite readily when called on something - when the electorate demands it. Look into the civil rights - is there any po
by smsm42 12y ago
Don't blame the parties. The parties react quite readily when called on something - when the electorate demands it. Look into the civil rights - is there any politician now openly opposing equal voting rights? No. Why - because all politicians are suddenly so high minded? No, because it's an extremely unpopular position and will get one's behind kicked on the election day. Now look at more controversial issue - say, gay marriage. Here we have politicians which wouldn't dream of taking position for or against - in certain places - and politicians readily taking the same position in another place. Why? Is it just random? No, it's because their electorate wants it, and politicians whose position does not match their electorate do not get elected. In fact, the president himself notably changed his position quite recently on the issue. Etc., etc. - I could name dozens of issues where politicians did whatever their electorate asked, and changed their tune when the electorate changed their opinion.
So why civil forfeiture is not an issue that effects change? Not because politicians are bad - they are bad in different ways, but at least in the US, their badness still can be controlled to a large measure. But because US citizens are not threatening to kick their politician's asses if they don't fix it. Like they do with many other hot topics of the day, quite successfully, one way or another. Why is that? I'm not sure. Maybe because civil forfeiture is something that usually happens to people that either linked to the criminal world or live in the places which are "sketchy" or don't have money and connections to raise the hype. Maybe because people are reluctant to criticize law enforcement. Maybe because it is served as a part of "war on drugs" and "think of the children", etc. Maybe there's another reason I completely miss - but whatever it is, the problem is not the politicians, the problem is that this issue is not taken as a serious problem by the society. If you want to blame somebody who could effect the change - blame the press. They probably could raise the profile of the issue if they wanted to. But they do not.
So the answer to the question of "who can stop them" - US citizens can. If only they'd want to.
- higherpurpose 12y agoMaybe that's the problem. The two parties are at best reactive. If we'd have a third or fourth party, we'd get parties actually pushing for something and raising awareness about a problem. Most people can't be bothered with this because "it doesn't happen to them".
- gizmo686 12y agoIs there a reason it needs to be the parties that push for change. If the parties are reactive to popular opinion, then we can influence policy through some non-party organization, such as the ACLU.
- AnthonyMouse 12y agoMore parties wouldn't fix anything. Under the US voting system they end up eating each other anyway, because whichever two parties are most alike do better to not run viable candidates against each other since that gives the election to the least similar party. I'm almost tempted to think that all the gerrymandering they've been doing could be a good thing because it takes the parties out of it. If your district is 80% one party then the primary is the election. Then you can vote for a primary candidate from that party who wants to fix the things you want fixed over the ones who don't. The problem is then they go to Washington and end up in a Congress which is approximately half of each party and everyone has a safe seat but there are no moderates, so instead of compromising somewhere in the middle you get winner take all and screw the other guys. But when you need House, Senate and President to pass a bill, that means unless one party controls all three nothing gets passed and if one party does then we get some kind of unaccountable shit tornado that one way or another kills thousands of Americans and adds five trillion dollars to the debt. So I'm going to have to say the gerrymandering is net negative (and half of the problem). The other half is that the federal government is doing things that it shouldn't. Even if you think recreational drugs should be illegal, how is that a federal issue whatsoever? There are still dry counties in this country and there is nothing wrong with that, because that's what the people of those counties want. And judging by recent referendums, federal drug policy is not uniformly what the people want.