3 ms·
The Chimera of Human Advancement
- archgoon 12y agoAs a counterpoint, Stevens Pinker argues in "Better Angels of our Nature" that the world has become more peaceful in the past millenia. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Better_Angels_of_Our_Nature http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Better_Angels_of_Our_Natu... So although we might despair that humanity hasn't changed, it may well be the case that we are in fact making slow, albeit sometimes halting, progress.
- jal278 12y agoA counter-point to the 'halting human progress is good enough' argument: If technological advance enables a person or society to be more destructive by orders of magnitude, then humanity's outcome (even if we are progressing, albeit slowly) could still be catastrophic. Take atomic weapons: It is clear that as a society we are not ready for the responsibility that they grant us (e.g. they've edged us close to Armageddon a few more times than is comfortable).
- moron4hire 12y agoDon't get me wrong, I'm not arguing that nukes are a good idea, nor do I think anyone should have them, even countries that could meet the most stringent requirements of "responsibility", but doesn't the fact that we haven't destroyed ourselves yet rather much make it not clear that we're not responsible enough for nuclear weapons? Yes, we've come close to Armagettingiton a few times in the past, but don't you think the fact that we haven't demonstrated that responsibility ultimately won the day?
- Zigurd 12y agoThat's a bit like careening down the road narrowly missing a terrible collision a few times and saying "My driving is improving." Nuclear weapons are the most reliable way we have to destroy our civilization. We need to get rid of them as soon as possible.
- moron4hire 12y agoWell yeah, but if you successfully do it for 50 years, are you a bad driver or are you just competing in a racing league? Again, my point is, it's not "clear".
- jqm 12y agoReligion and philosophy have tried for millennium to change human character. They have been unsuccessful for the most part, and this failure will likely continue. Because.... we are bound by biology. Change that and everything changes. And this is the threshold where we stand right now. I don't know where it leads. But I'm pretty sure it is the future. Never bet against technology in favor of philosophy.
- waps 12y agoTLDR: Technology ("human achievement") is useless because "it doesn't give us greatness (of character)" (note that they believe that any worldly possession or anything that makes life easier is fleeting and thus worthless) I can understand that a 5 year old believes this, or someone who is homeless with no possible way out. It strikes me as a viewpoint that is designed to keep the homeless/the extreme poor "in their place". Convince them that it's not even worth it to try to improve their situation, that God himself would oppose that (maybe gods would be the more appropriate word ?). I bet any smart tax-collecting ruler would be a huge fan of this faith. For anyone else I think their everyday experiences will contradict this way of thinking enough to convince them otherwise. I think that it is in fact possible, desirable and worth it to try to improve myself and my situation (economical, technological, literary, knowledge, familial, ...). Improving my character is only a component of that, necessary but far from sufficient, and technology helps a LOT, though admittedly probably not with the character part.