6 ms·
The 2014 Mac Mini reviewed
- protomyth 12y agoIts actually more expensive when you try to get near what the 2012 model had. They really messed this one up. 2 cores not 4, soldered RAM, and no 2 hard drives. I wish Apple would throw people who cannot buy the Mac Pro a bone, but that's not the way of a consumer electronics company.
- mmastrac 12y agoUgh. This is the trend that will finally push me off Apple desktop/laptop hardware: "you'll finally see that the new Mac Mini's RAM is soldered directly to the motherboard. It's no longer user-upgradeable, so make sure you order all the RAM you need when you buy the computer in the first place."
- jiggy2011 12y agoI wonder why they did this? In the case of the macbooks and iMacs at least, it can be somewhat justified as a space saving measure. However the new mini is the same size as the old one and it's already quite tiny.
- jlcx 12y agoI think that's what lots of people are wondering. There doesn't seem to be a good reason here, from the customer's point of view. It looks like they're just trying to push people to buy new machines instead of upgrading the old ones, which is disappointing. I was waiting for the update, and I even bought one, but I returned it a few days later; too much about it just wasn't acceptable.
- danieldk 12y agoIt looks like they're just trying to push people to buy new machines instead of upgrading the old ones, which is disappointing. Or getting power users to buy the non-base models. I have a 2012 Mac Mini base model, and upgraded it to 16 GB RAM and a 256GB SSD for little cost. It should go without saying that I'll keep it for a while and probably double the SSD in some point in the future.
- jlcx 12y agoIf Apple were just trying to get people to buy upgraded stuff from them, I'd understand. But they're not even doing that very well; the $699 configuration minis still come standard with a 5400 rpm spinning disk, for example, and SSDs and 16GB RAM are both considered "customized Macs" that you can't just walk into any Apple Store and buy.
- jeangenie 12y agoA) Most users will never open their computer for any reason, including upgrading RAM. B) Apple wants to capture the cost of upgrading their hardware in the future.
- pbreit 12y agoC) Apple wants to capture the cost of more RAM in the present.
- jlcx 12y agoThe "most users" thing might be technically true, but I bet a lot of the minis belonging to those users were still being upgraded after being sold by the original owners. I think "capture" is the key word. They're not trying to create wealth for their users with this action; they're trying to capture it for their company and its shareholders.
- taylorbuley 12y agoPresuming the market for Macs is relatively fixed, and that soldered RAM was the "status quo" configuration previous to recent iterations, it's plausible that the change to user-upgradable RAM to impacted sales for other, higher margin Macs in a noticeable, provable way.
- tammer 12y agoOf course the other comments are true, but I could easily see Apple justifying this as a reduction in power draw. They made a big deal out of the mini's efficency at the keynote.
- danieldk 12y agoJustification or excuse? For a desktop machine it is not that much of an issue. And since Mac Minis are already using mobile CPUs, they were already very low-power compared to other desktop machines. There is always an excuse. In reality, they have changed their model to 'upgrades only at purchase'. Unfortunately, their machines are so good that we all accept this...
- seanp2k2 12y agoHackintosh on a NUC seems like the way to go at this point. It'd be interesting if Apple just started using actual NUCs instead of making their own inferior version.
- judk 12y agoDoes non-soldered RAM draw more power??
- smackfu 12y agoOne tangible reason is support costs. A new Mac mini is never going to the Genius Bar because of bad third party memory, or badly seated memory, or a static shock administered to the mother board while the memory was being changed. Even if those are quite rare, support incidents can be expensive, so it could be a dollar or two average per mini being saved.
- trvz 12y agoThose situations might be less rare than you think, the savings tens of dollars and contributors to the lower price.
- appleflaxen 12y agoI know I'm not the typical consumer, but I would be /so happy/ to pay a dollar to have removable memory.
- jacquesm 12y agoI remember when CMOS was new and static really did damage just about every part you handled if you weren't careful. Little conductive wrist band connected to steel desk, carbon coated conductive foam to work on and so on. But for the life of me I can't remember when a part failed due to static in the last decade or even longer. If anything broke it was either a cable or a soldered connection to a board. Sure, I've had RAM break, but that was factory installed RAM that was several years old. This is definitely anecdata but it would be interesting to know how much damage static really does these days. If you're going out of your way to pet your cat prior to installing your RAM chips on a glass floor or something like that then you're probably asking for it. But regular precautions (place RAM container on the case before opening package, hold the case while inserting the RAM) seem to be more than enough. On chip ESD protection has come a long way since the 80's. http://www.amazon.com/On-Chip-Protection-Integrated-Circuits-International/dp/0792376471 http://www.amazon.com/On-Chip-Protection-Integrated-Circuits...
- rdtsc 12y agoPresumably everything they do is to make more money. Let's just say that customers who buy base models then go on newegg and add memory or replace hard drives, put on their static arm bands, open cases and match connectors and so on, are not their target audience. They would like people to go buy a higher end model. The profit on RAM is probably pretty good given performance boost vs the cost of RAM. It is an opportunit they would be silly to waste.
- judk 12y agoIt undermines/reinforces their brand though. These misleading sticker prices with car-salesman trim levels piss off users except the Mercedes class who enjoy conspicuous consumption.
- cherry_su 12y agoProbably for ease of design and manufacturing. Apple raids the corporate parts bin: the lowest SKU, like the base iMac, is a MacBook Air in a box. The mid and high tier SKUs are repackaged 13" MacBook Pros.
- radley 12y agoThis was the deal breaker for me. I ordered it on the release day and only found out the truth a few days later. I returned it unopened (I only ordered 8GB - was going to just add my own RAM). Instead of spending $1300 for marginal improvements, I bought a $125 256GB SSD and upped my 2012 Mini to a fusion drive.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- hcarvalhoalves 12y agoThe maximum RAM this model accepts is 16GB. 3 years down the line it's more likely you'll just buy a new model instead of hunting deprecated RAM modules. And for the people who need a lot of RAM, they need it now, not later. I know the benefits of RAM upgrades - I even had a Pentium MMX with 128mb in the old days - but I don't see it making sense nowadays for consumer hardware like the Mini.
- self 12y agoAre you sure about that? My work MBP is a mid-2009 2.6 GHz Core 2 Duo; upgrading the RAM to 8 GB means I can keep Chrome (with 30+ tabs open) running while working in Xcode or Android Studio. This wouldn't have been possible if I was stuck with the 4 GB it shipped with. It probably cost a lot more to configure it with 8 GB in 2009 than it did to upgrade the modules last year.
- hcarvalhoalves 12y agoPlease notice you're comparing the 2009 hardware with the 2014 market - 5 years. The Mac Mini has a RAM cap that is just 2x the amount you have right now, which you already judge is enough. What's the logic in making it upgradeable? Just buy it maxed out now. It's not like you would be able to upgrade it to 64GB in 5 years if it had a slot. Actually, it's likely you won't even find a RAM module with the right specs in 5 years, the industry is changing specs every 6 months.
- fakename 12y agoI also have a 2009 macbook pro. I bought it with 2gb ram (or was it 1gb?--can't remember) upgrading to 8gb at the time would have cost me like 3-400. I upgraded to 4gb for about $50 in 2011, and upgraded to $8gb in 2013 for another ~$50.
- to3m 12y agoI did something similar too. This is actually very bad for Apple - because I've now had the same Macbook Pro for 5.25 years, and it's remaining serviceable thanks to RAM upgrades and a modern high-capacity SSD. I'm sure it will end up lasting 5.5 years and it seems like there's a fair chance it will (Apple software support and wobbly ports permitting...) last for 6. But if they'd forced me to pay for all the upgrades up front, I'd probably still have bought the same spec (the 8GB RAM option was eye-wateringly expensive at the time, and the SSDs were comically pricey) - and then I'd have had to buy a whole new one after 2 years. Which probably wouldn't have had an SSD, because they were still expensive back then. So I'd probably be buying another one round about now, if not before, and Apple would have had 3 purchases out of me rather than just one.
- threatofrain 12y agoI think what frustrates me most is not the RAM, but the hard drive. I feel that the future will be kind to 4-8 GB of RAM, and I guess I'm willing to pay extra for RAM, but the hard drive options puts the price too high for me, and the options themselves are meh when I'd rather have my own SSD. It's frustrating to know that I am probably a minority customer, and thus Apple will probably never cater to me again. All the while I know that if only I had enough money, then I could be a happier Apple customer (I think the happiest Apple customers live in the middle-to-upper price tiers). If and when I get more successful, I'll consider Apple, but until then, I can see that Apple is no longer the best fit for me.
- cicero 12y agoI had a similar reaction to changes in the iMac last year that reduced the ability to upgrade. After owning mostly Macs since my 512K Fat Mac in 1985, I decided to build my own PC last Christmas, and I've been very happy with it. I then decided to replace my wife's MacBook with a Toshiba. She has only used Macs, but it hasn't taken her long to get used to and be happy with the Toshiba, and it only cost me $375. I have realized that I can no longer afford to be an Apple customer, and as the margin of any advantage Apple products previously had over the competition has greatly reduced, I don't see the point anymore. It is sad for me because my relationship with Apple began when my dad brought home an Apple II in 1977, but all good things in this world eventually come to an end.
- Adirael 12y agoI tried to do this, but I just don't like working with Windows (or Linux). I don't like their current line of hardware, nothing fits me. iMacs: too rigid, I wan't my own screen. Mac Pro: too expensive, too powerful. Mac Mini? Soldered RAM, 5400RPM drive. If I max it out it's cheaper to get an iMac. I ended getting a PC and throwing OS X on it. It's a pain in the ass when things break but it works for me. I would love a more upgrade-friendly Mini with desktop and not laptop hardware, even if it has to be bigger.
- JeremyMorgan 12y agoI posted this a few days ago: https://twitter.com/JeremyCMorgan/status/529727399353937922 https://twitter.com/JeremyCMorgan/status/529727399353937922 I was curious because of the differences in the U vs M processor so I went into Best Buy and ran Geekbench on one. I know CPU isn't everything... but what exactly would be a reason for putting a power saving CPU in something that's plugged into the wall? My current Mini already uses far less power than any of my old stand up PCs of the past. I'm kind of puzzled what the selling point to the Mini is now. At first it was an affordable Mac for those who don't have the money (or want to spend the money) for a pro, but at this point it seems to just be an underpowered box you can't upgrade for roughly the same price as a macbook air or better powered PC.
- Osmium 12y ago> but what exactly would be a reason for putting a power saving CPU in something that's plugged into the wall? Devil's advocate, but I imagine it'd do huge things to the country's energy bill if everyone's computer was as energy efficient as new Core U-based computers.
- jarek 12y agoIt really wouldn't. Your fridge's power usage eclipses any computer you might have, short of a hardcore overclocked rig running Folding 24/7. To say nothing of electric stoves, A/C and heating, or industrial electricity usage. Hell, at the 20-30 W levels of lighter-powered computers, a couple of light bulbs might make a bigger difference.
- mikeyouse 12y agoAll of those things you listed are used only intermittently which dramatically reduces their consumption. Many computers are on 24/7, especially Mac Minis and other things used for media servers. There was a good article recently about the insane energy demand from DVRs -- they use more energy than any other home appliance, excepting air conditioning used in hot climates. http://www.latimes.com/nation/la-na-power-hog-20140617-story.html#page=1 http://www.latimes.com/nation/la-na-power-hog-20140617-story...
- zrail 12y agoI have been using a 2012 mini as a home server, but recently when I needed to upgrade I decided to get a Dell T20. Cheaper, more and more powerful cores, and lots of internal expansion possibilities. Of course, the trade off is that it's considerably bigger, but it's just sitting in a closet at home so it's not a big deal. Oh, and at idle it only uses 20 watts, about the same as the mini.
- th0ma5 12y agoI got a Zotac Zbox a while ago instead of a mini and was wondering if anyone else has seen any nifty things in the micro ATX world?
- lhl 12y agoThere's a lot of neat small x86 stuff, but a lot of it depends on whether you're going low power or not. If what you want is something like a Mac Mini but w/ higher end i7's your options are some Intel NUC or Gigabyte BRIX's which will be significantly more expensive than a baseline 2014 Mac Mini (but a bit cheaper when you match high-end RAM/SSD) - no TB2 or OSX (some ugly Hackintosh hacks withstanding) though. Gigabyte's BRIX Gaming is interesting since it has a GK104M based "GTX 760," which is amazing for the form-factor, but the trade-off is in relative cost and jet turbine fans. (The Alienware Alpha, Zotac EN760, and Asus GR8 are other "smallish" devices w/ dedicated GPUs). You can get some really cheap/small Celeron-based NUC-sized machines (~$150 bare-bones) and throw in RAM/SSD for a very nice low-power Linux system. We use a lot of these at work at the moment, these are great. Most of the fun stuff going on is with low power Bay Trail processors. Zotac has the C-series, which is between a NUC and Mac Mini in size, but also a Pico series (PI320) which is tiny, much smaller than the ECS Liva or the Minix Neo Z64 (which are also tiny). Also, there's the MEEGO-T01, which is the first Bay Trail HDMI stick I've seen.
- badsock 12y agoMy main desktop machine is an Asus Chromebox with an upgraded SSD and Linux installed. Had a hex-core 3.8GHz tower sitting right beside it, but I found I never booted it. I spend most of my life in terminal windows, but it runs FireFox, the Gimp, and older games like HL2 just fine. Fan almost never goes on.
- rogy 12y agoWe'd been waiting to replace our '12 minis with new ones in the office, but have instead just gone for MBP retinas. Can't see any reason to go with the minis now they're not upgradeable at all, other than price.
- pptr1 12y agoWhy does it need to be replaced? '12 mini would still be going strong.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- louwrentius 12y agoThe $500 Mini is a dishonest lie by Apple. Look at what happens when you give the 1.4 Ghz model 8 GB Ram and a fusion drive, it costs $850. If you take the 2.6 Ghz model, you end up with $900 for that configuration. A 50$ price difference for a 1.4 vs 2.6 Ghz processor. The Mac Mini performance and pricing is just maddening.
- nodata 12y agoThey're trying to kill it.
- wj 12y agoWhy try to kill it? Why not just do it by not offering it anymore?
- officemonkey 12y agoApple isn't one monolithic creature. I'm assuming that some are trying to kill it (by making it underpowered with low sales) because they can't kill it politically (it's one of Steve's babies.) It's kinda like the old iPod. They kept making it _long_ after nobody bought one, because it was the iconic turn-around device for Apple. Cook admitted they had to stop making it because they couldn't find parts anymore.
- smackfu 12y agoI doubt it. It's just the "bad low-end model" strategy that Apple has used for a long time. You make the base model cheap, but give it some flaws that knowledgeable buyers just can't ignore. This might be a slow processor, or a slow HDD, or not enough RAM. Then you make it so the base model can't be upgraded easily. The "cheap" buyer still buys the base model, but other buyers go up-model and you make more money off of them.
- Retric 12y agoThere is nothing wrong with using the base model as is without upgrading RAM or getting a SSD. Sure, it's only got 4GB of ram and a 500GB HDD, but that's fine for a wide range of uses. Don't forget a second PC at home can always stream your primary desktop so there is little point to getting multiple high end computers for personal use. Leaving things like a secondary computer for guests or streaming music / video and some light surfing. Making cheap, light, quiet, and low power far more important than a quad cores or a high end video card.
- rdl 12y agoI predict these will be pretty short lived; there will be a Late-2015 Mac Mini with 4K 60Hz which hopefully also fixes the quad core problem (lack of). Sticking with my 2011 and 2012; I might upgrade the 2011 to a 2012 if I can get a cheap refurb.
- jdechko 12y agoIn theory it's off-putting, but in practice I'm not really bothered by the changes. If I were to buy one, it would only be as a home server for iTunes Library hosting (to AppleTV) and as a backup destination for CrashPlan. My current server is an old Dell desktop that draws a lot of power and it's pretty noisy. Even the base configuration of the mini is plenty for what I would want to do with it.
- broknbottle 12y agoIt would appear they are just offering what Intel has available. I'm guess the Intel I5-4260U as it's 1.4GHz w/ Intel 5000 Graphics. It doesn't look like Intel even offers a mobile version of i5 with 4 cores and I couldn't find a mobile i7 with 4 cores and intel 5000+ graphics. This is one area A10 APUs that AMD really has Intel beat.
- kylec 12y agoIntel does offer quad-core mobile chips with Intel 5000+ graphics. Apple's even shipping them in the 15" retina MacBook Pro. Here's the mid-tier chip: http://ark.intel.com/products/83504/Intel-Core-i7-4870HQ-Processor-6M-Cache-up-to-3_70-GHz http://ark.intel.com/products/83504/Intel-Core-i7-4870HQ-Pro... The issue with using these in the Mac mini, as mentioned in the article, is that they require a different socket than the dual-core i5 chips. If Apple wanted to offer both dual and quad-core chips in the Mac mini, they'd need to design and ship two different boards. It might have been more costly to do so, but I think that Apple's doing their customers a great disservice by not offering something between a dual-core i5 with soldered RAM and the $3K Mac Pro.
- broknbottle 12y agoah Thank you for pointing that out. I think the rMBP is actually a great middle of the road option. It supports multiple monitors with 2xthunderbolt,1xhdmi. I've seen lots of companies opting for these over mac minis and just having employees dock them in clamshell mode.
- gatehouse 12y agoGigabyte makes a mini system with i7-4770R, which is 4 core, Iris pro 5200 graphics, similar size to the mac mini: http://www.gigabyte.com/products/product-page.aspx?pid=4888#ov http://www.gigabyte.com/products/product-page.aspx?pid=4888#... It is a bit noisy thought, I'm not sure the design of the mac mini could dissipate this much heat.
- bronson 12y agoI made a quick video with the same conclusion: stay on 2012 and wait until a worthy upgrade comes along. (Well, unless you want PCIe SSD I/O bandwith -- that's much faster. But multicore is sooo much slower that it's not a clear win.) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QmmkD2rgNgA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QmmkD2rgNgA No need to watch the video, all the info is in the description.
- andyl 12y agoIntel NUCs are similar in size to Mac Mini - I've been using for small linux servers and dev boxes. NUCs can handle 16GB ram, quad-core, SSD, GB ethernet. Small and quiet - a great little device.
- judk 12y agoWhat are good retail NUCs?