8 ms·
Big things to expect from Emacs 25
- elwell 12y agoConcurrency in elisp would bring the benefits that Chrome brought with it's thread-per-tab design. I feel like I'm in the 80's when I can't touch my other windows while the repl gets loaded; and crossing my fingers that it doesn't crash emacs.
- hollerith 12y agoWhat "REPL" do you use that locks up Emacs while it loads? Unless I am very much mistaken, cmuscheme.el (a.k.a. Inferior Scheme mode) and all the other modes derived from Comint do not ever lock up Emacs.
- rprospero 12y agoNot a repl, but I often have to stop coding for five minutes when I load up gnus.
- RBerenguel 12y agoI switched to nognus for better speed, and recently made the jump to mu4e with offlineimap. And I'm already in love, so fast and non-blocking when refreshing emails! Of course, I could have had offlineimap with gnus, but it was a tedious setup (when I checked) and mu4e was quite a breeze. Local indexed search is so good I'm don't care that much now about filing emails anymore.
- elwell 12y agoclojure nrepl in cider
- malandrew 12y agoI honestly don't understand why many such services aren't designed as APIs that any editor can interact with via an API. TernJS is an example of a tool that takes this approach[0]. Just make the solutions for each of the problems needing to be solved LISPy. Wouldn't it be great if one day other editors are using LISP based language tools via API in their text editor of choice. http://ternjs.net/ http://ternjs.net/
- zura 12y agoOne question for long time Emacs users - do you notice any significant changes compared to e.g. 10 or 20 years ago versions of Emacs? Same question applies to vim users I believe... Like, for instance, there are huge advancements from MSVC 97 to MSVC 2013...
- RBerenguel 12y agoNot a lot in vanilla emacs (the executable, bare) but I definitely feel a surge in awesome elisp libraries from 10 years ago.
- jasonm23 12y agoI'm not sure the bare executable is what most people consider to be Emacs (well not its users anyway!), since the large percentage of the code is emacslisp.
- RBerenguel 12y agoWith bare executable I mean just a bare, recently downloaded emacs with no additional libraries. Emacs is understood to be together with its accompanying libraries.. I think even find-file is implemented in emacs-lisp
- jasonm23 12y agoAs a user of Emacs for about 18 years, the answer is absolutely. In recent years, since 23.0, it feels as if Emacs has improved a great deal. This is largely due to the introduction of package.el (extension / package management.) To put it in slightly more dramatic terms, it's revolutionized it.
- unhammer 12y agoSome things that come to mind: * --daemon with emacsclient was a big improvement in usability (ie. "instant startup" by keeping it running all the time) * As others have said, there's been a surge in elisp packages lately, thanks to package.el and friends * Changing color themes and fonts used to be a real hassle, but no more. * Unicode (and bidi) Just Works now, no magic incantations in ~/.emacs needed any more * org-mode! Ten years ago, org-mode was just started and not yet a part of Emacs. I think I first installed it as an addon around 2005, but at the time it was quite barebones compared to what it is now … (and of course installing it and keeping it up-to-date was a lot more work than doing the same for any third-party package now). ----- This question prompted me to look at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GNU_Emacs#Release_history https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GNU_Emacs#Release_history – other things I enjoy from that list include: * good fullscreen support in X, * lexical binding (not something you need most of the time, but indispensible when you do need it), * docview (PROTIP: docview is better than most pdf viewers for copy-pasting text from pdf's), * nXML (awesome XML editor), * dbus bindings – can be handy, * tramp! ohmydog tramp didn't even exist ten years ago! And people were using c-mode to highlight CSS files … So yes, significant changes noticed :-)
- ed0 12y agoI personally use Vim but I like Emacs as well. They are both great. But they are getting old and it shows. Compare them to the super nice text rendering of ST3. I understand one cannot use ST3 from the terminal but that's fine. I can continue to use vim in that case. But 99% of my time is spent in graphical environment and I want a modern editor with nice font rendering and all. But still, IMHO Vim and Emacs are better text editors than ST3. Why can't we have best of both worlds? Implement core vim functionality as a backend service and provide a modern frontend with nice rendering (by using Skia for example). Same goes for Emacs. It's time to move on but keep the best of Vim and Emacs.
- rasur 12y agoI get your point but fwiw Emacs in a modern mac terminal is not completely horrible to look at.
- edwintorok 12y agoHow does ST3's rendering compare to GVim? You can select a different font for GVim, I personally prefer Source Code Pro for example.
- hrvbr 12y agoIt depends on the quality of your screen. On my previous laptop I had a high-quality WLED screen and ST3 looked clearly better than everything else on Windows. On my current cheap laptop however, everything looks quite pixelated anyways and I actually prefer the rendering of gVim or Notepad++.
- ed0 12y agoGVim is not that bad to be honest, but in my experience ST3 is still better. It's not just the font rendering. The whole UI experience in GVim is lacking compared to ST3. ST3 has been designed for the modern UI environment and Vim and Emacs haven't. That's the point.
- edwintorok 12y agoCan you point me to an article with more details on this? I use my text editor mainly from the keyboard, I very rarely use the mouse (it would be a lot slower), so the only reason to use GVim (vs a terminal Vim) would be font rendering / color themes. Does the UI experience you refer to primarily to mouse use, or something else?
- cujo 12y agoI love emacs, but it seems like most of my programming for pay is trending towards languages where there is a huge advantage to using a "modern" ide. I'm talking mainly of java/jvm languages and objc here. I don't expect emacs (the community really) to all of a sudden provide awesome packages for that type of development, but it saddens me that I get more locked in to these other ides that I don't view as generally superior.
- nyir 12y agoAt least for Java (and probably most other languages) (emacs-)eclim can leverage Eclipse functionality (for Emacs, Vim, ...). So you'll get the same completion, refactoring methods and so on. https://github.com/senny/emacs-eclim https://github.com/senny/emacs-eclim, http://eclim.org/ http://eclim.org/
- craigching 12y agoHow do I not know about this?!?!?! Thanks for sharing the link, do you have any experience to share? Does it work well? EDIT: If this works as advertised here [1] then I am all in! [1] -- http://www.skybert.net/emacs/java/ http://www.skybert.net/emacs/java/
- 3rd3 12y agoIt would actually be cool to have a ninite.com for Emacs configurations, where one could choose from the best pre-configured crowd-sourced Emacs versions for several use cases and platforms (e.g. web-design, Java-programming or reproducible research). Sure, extending Emacs from scratch is fun, but many people are probably reluctant having to spend many hours to achieve a good configuration because they are not guaranteed to benefit from the result.
- cujo 12y agoBut you then need eclipse installed also right? I use intellij for my java needs and it makes me content the bulk of the time. Having used emacs + jdee back in the day I'm afraid of the lost hours to trying emacs+<insert hack here> again.
- ZenoArrow 12y agoSome great features listed for Emacs 25, sounds promising. Personally I hope that Ergo Emacs can be merged into the main Emacs branch, as an alternative keybinding option (not a mode). Some might say, why not just use Ergo Emacs? The way I see it, it's too much work for a small group of developers to create new key bindings for all Emacs packages. By moving it into mainline (as an option), package developers know the option is available by default and can choose whether they want to support it.
- ZenoArrow 12y agoMarked down for that? Why?
- mwfogleman 12y agoBecause this is a wishlist, not a changelog.
- ZenoArrow 12y agoI somewhat doubt it was anything to do with me mentioning a version number, and all to do with having the audacity to suggest I'd like a comprehensive keybinding alternative (it's the weakest element in Emacs, in my personal opinion).
- JasonFruit 12y agoWhat I want from Emacs 25 is to not have to use vi when I want to edit a large file without line-breaks. Okay, maybe I need a more powerful machine — but I shouldn't.
- hollerith 12y agoI'm guessing that the reason you resort to vi is that scrolling through the editing buffer is slow. Have you tried visiting the file with M-x hexl-find-file?
- JasonFruit 12y agoNo, but why would I want to edit it as hex? Maybe I'm missing something obvious?
- hollerith 12y agoIn Hexl mode, scrolling is vastly faster -- and it shows the file as characters as well as as hex somewhat like the Unix program strings does. M-: (hexl-find-file (concat invocation-directory invocation-name)) It's no big deal, but if it is not the speed of scrolling, then I do not understand what it is about Emacs that discourages you from using it on large files without line-breaks.
- JasonFruit 12y agoThat is an improvement, but I still wish I could open it like any other text file. Still, thanks for a viable method.
- gnufx 12y ago"Dynamically loading libraries is a big deal, and it's closer than ever." Sigh. Dynamically loaded C extensions were working long ago <https://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/gnu-emacs-sources/2002-04/msg00012.html> https://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/gnu-emacs-sources/2002-04.... It wasn't even a "big" thing -- most of the change was in the build system. rms wouldn't let them in because he (via Moglen?) thought they would undermine the copyleft. That was worrying as a design criterion was to make them (almost?) equivalent at compile time and after loading to things built into the Emacs core normally, so that derived work status should be clear in a court. Perhaps eventually someone will re-do other things, like replacing the GC.