7 ms·
Are the smart getting richer?
- madair 17y agoSocial darwinism rears its ugly head in odd places. Luck and intelligence can each work alone to produce fortunes. But after the initial fortune is made, only intelligence helps grow it. Wow.
- jsankey 17y agoThis appears to completely ignore the fact that money gives you power, privilege and opportunity - and that can be used to make more money. It's not impossible to get rich from nothing, but you start with a huge disadvantage.
- HeyLaughingBoy 17y agoI think if you studied it, you'd find that most people who start out with a lot of money, end up with less, not more. The smart poor are hungrier and more willing to take risks. And that's what really hit home for me: when he made the comment that risk counted more than hard work. I work for a company whose stock was severely depressed last spring. I know our fundamentals are good, we're a leader in a growing, relatively recession-resistant industry and that the stock would probably bounce back in a year. So I considered buying a $10k block of it when it dropped below half normal price, but chickened out when I realized that I couldn't afford to lose $10k or so if I was wrong. What happened? Exactly what I guessed: the stock is now back to to its high 60's-low 70's level and I would have made an easy $10,000 had I made the investment a year ago. Reminds me how bourgeois I've become :-( Losing my stomach for risk!!
- barrkel 17y agoI can make exactly the opposite argument: the poor can't afford to take risks, so the smart poor don't. It's one thing to be poor and desperate enough to take risks to survive, but when you have enough to survive reasonably comfortably, you need another buffer before you can take risks that can really pay off. Someone with 10K to spare - I mean really to spare - in your situation would have made that money. If you were even tighter for money, I don't think you would have been less risk averse - on the contrary, you'd be even tighter with it.
- HeyLaughingBoy 17y agoMy ability to accept risk these days depends more on the downside than the upside. This was radically different 10 years ago. At that time I would have seen the opportunity to make an easy $10k and gone for it. If I lost the money, well I could always make more. These days I have a hefty mortgage and a family to support. Losing the 10k won't put us on the street, but it takes a big bite out of our safety net. It wasn't worth the risk, especially with the economy tanking. In retrospect, my comment was poorly phrased since I had myself in mind as the "smart poor." Upon reflection I can see that it wasn't the lack of money that made me so willing to take risks without much of a buffer, it was the lack of responsibilities.
- ahlatimer 17y agoThat tends to happen as you age. Values and priorities shift drastically as you get older and, presumably, take on more responsibilities (children, wife, etc.). This is played out pretty heavily in politics. Young people tend to be more liberal and grow more conservative as time goes on with the possibility of again moving back towards the liberal side of things at the end when responsibilities start to dissipate (children grow up, social security kicks in, etc.). I think the key is to take risks when you have the ability to (i.e. when you're young). It doesn't mean you can't grow rich later in life, but I have a feeling that the longer you put off taking on the "big" responsibility, the higher the probability you will be to succeed in a financial sense. If your idea of "successful" is to have a spouse and offspring, by all means, pursue that as early as possible. If it's to be financially well off, you'd be better off pursuing that instead of a family.
- astine 17y agoNo it doesn't. He said that the expression, 'the rich are getting richer,' is a generalization (which it is) but that it is 'true enough.' Money is a tool with which you can aquire more wealth, but all the tools in the world are worthless if you don't have the knowhow to use them.
- dstorrs 17y agoThe bar is pretty low for "enough knowhow" in this case, however. Basically: 1) I have $10M. 2) I don't know a dang thing about investing. 3) I better find someone who does (e.g., Vanguard), and let them manage my money for me while I keep an eye on them to make sure they behave responsibly. ----------- OT joke that amused me: Stock call? Is that when you stand on the porch and yell for the cows?
- abossy 17y agoThere was a recent discussion in the econoblogosphere that provides statistical evidence to back up jsankey's argument: Initial post: http://gregmankiw.blogspot.com/2009/08/least-surprising-correlation-of-all.html http://gregmankiw.blogspot.com/2009/08/least-surprising-corr... Response: http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/08/28/heredity-environment-justice/ http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/08/28/heredity-environ... Conclusion: http://gregmankiw.blogspot.com/2009/08/test-scores-and-income.html http://gregmankiw.blogspot.com/2009/08/test-scores-and-incom... The summary is that for both adopted children and non-adopted children, the higher the father's income, the higher the resulting test scores. Hence, money makes you smarter.
- known 17y agoaka http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Principle http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Principle
- biohacker42 17y agoWow. I know he's cartoonist and it is literally his job to over simply, but still wow!
- jpwagner 17y agoTwo comments: 1. "Smart" is not a scalar; "rich" is. 2. True that hard work alone will not make you rich, but [extreme] hard work coupled with working-on-the-right-thing has a very high chance of making you rich.
- mmt 17y agoI don't believe "rich" is a scalar, either. When I look for a firm definition, it appears to be, in effect, accumulated wealth (however one might define it). However, especially in a taxation context, I hear it associated with, if not equated to, income. (Granted, this could merely be an artifact of a taxation system which relies heavily on taxing income). Let's put that aside and use the "something people want" definition of wealth. One can certainly convert to a scalar value (money) a particular form of wealth (asset) at a particular point in time (i.e. sell it). However, since the reverse is not true, (e.g. just because, if I had it, I could sell the Mona Lisa for $X does not mean there is a value of $Y for which I could buy it if I didn't have it), it seems safe to say they are of a different type. Although that doesn't mean that wealth itself is not a scalar, I contend that any additional dimension, not bidirectionally convertible to a scalar does. Risk (e.g. that people will want an item more or less) is such a dimension. Inherent depreciation is another. Scarcity is, arguably, another. Perhaps a more compelling situation is where a particular asset is worth more when concentrated, such as fissionable material or arable land. The former has what one could consider a sharp increase in value at "critical mass," whereas the latter increases more steadily due to economy of scale. Perhaps "smart" is the same kind of non-scalar, but I'll let someone else exercise that conjecture.
- jpwagner 17y agoI'd define "rich" as |wealth| You may define it differently, but that's language isn't it.
- prewett 17y agoAlthough "Rich Dad, Poor Dad" is a pretty terrible book, I liked his definition of "rich": how long can you live your life without working. (Of course, a more precise definition would need to factor in standard of living)
- rauljara 17y agoThe formula for success is apparently: Intelligence + hard work + risk taking + luck I want to focus on risk taking, because Mr. Adams mentioned that the degree to which risk taking rewards you is a function of intelligence. It seems like in the recent economic downturn capitalism did reward good risk taking in say, the banking industry, but it also failed to punish bad risk taking, as many of the same people who caused the crisis still received their bonuses, and probably will well into the future. The phrase the rich get richer tends to resonate because very often the rich engage in behaviors which would result in serious consequences for the poor, but for which the rich only seem to get rewarded.
- pchristensen 17y agoThere are two ways to take a risk: 1) Bet on something unlikely and get lucky 2) Have an advantage over others so that your chance of success is higher than the average chance of success. #2 is pg's approach to startups - starting a company is "risky", but starting a company if you're determined, smart, and connected to a system that turns entrepreneurs into companies isn't risky at all, with a ~50%+ success rate. On a sinister note, insider trading falls into this category too - the market isn't a random walk if you know information that will move it, and your information gives you an advantage over the average investor.
- roc 17y agoI have met many smart poor people. I have met many dumb rich people. I've never met someone with business savvy who was poor (for long). As near as I can tell, capitalism doesn't reward the smart at all. But it rewards those with business savvy. Maybe some people call that intelligence. I don't. It's more an ability to shrewdly calculate just how much you can take advantage of other people and get away with.
- ajju 17y agoAre you saying that being business savvy always requires taking advantage of other people?
- roc 17y agoNo. I'm saying that it requires the awareness of how you could. E.g. Being an intelligent chemist necessarily implies that you could, say, build a bomb. You might never do it. And if you did, you might do it in as-ethical a way as possible. But you still need to know how to blow things up. Similarly with business. You may never leverage that knowledge, but someone else might. And you need to know how to protect yourself from that.
- ajju 17y agoI see. In my experience people who take advantage of other people may gain in the short run but in the long run they always lose. Most people I deal with are not stupid (and I prefer it that way). They can tell when they are being taken advantage of and would not put up with it. Dealing with them fairly, sometimes at my own expense, has worked in my favor in the long run. But it makes sense that you be smart enough to know when you are being taken advantage of.
- gjm11 17y agoSuppose you meet someone who is poor. How do you tell whether they have "business savvy", and how do you avoid your judgement of that being affected by the fact that you know they're poor?
- ajscherer 17y agoHe dismisses hard work because it exists at all income levels, yet intelligence also exists at all income levels and he considers it the dominant factor. He needs to demonstrate that intelligence is more correlated to present wealth than work ethic is. He also dismisses risk taking as only being useful in combination with intelligence. Can he provide an example of an intelligent person who became rich in the absence of risk taking, hard work, and luck? Wealth being equivalent to intelligence must be a very flattering idea if you are rich, but I have observed many smart and hard working people who do not become rich.
- jibiki 17y agoI had expected the opposite argument. Dilbert is pretty smart, but he sure isn't rich. His boss, on the other hand...
- pradocchia 17y agoAm I the only one who finds some irony here? I mean, the man made his fortunate satirizing the managerial class.
- johnnybgoode 17y agoThis sounds a lot like some of PG's essays, where he tries to break something complex down into a few character traits. I wonder if the reactions here would be different if PG had written this, too.
- unalone 17y agoThey would be. I don't think it's just that Paul is famous here and Scott Adams isn't, though certainly there's always a pro-YC bias present. Part of it is also that Paul's essays have a very clear style about them, and they've got a confidence about what they're saying. So combine something convincing along with a community inclined to like the something and you get overwhelming support. That's why I was astonished the first time I read MeFi's commentary on a Graham essay. There, the community is much more critical, and it's more built to support multiple viewpoints. There was some interesting criticism that I found myself agreeing with a lot, and there were a few people that really hated both his essays and the YCombinator crowd. While I can't say I agree with their vitriol in full, it reminded me that even a bright, argumentative community has blind spots.
- DanielBMarkham 17y ago"Smart" is a word you can drive a truck through. "Smart" like Sam Walton? You betcha. As it should be "Smart" like a Nobel prize winner? Nope, and Nobel prize winners shouldn't all be rich. Smart can mean knowing things, discovering things, applying things, or a combination of all of those attributes and more. In this case, the word "smart" is very misleading.
- hyperbovine 17y agoWhat is smart? There is no proper definition of smart so it's a pointless question. Many people seem to define "smart" as "good at making money" in which case of course the smart are getting richer. If you consider musical smarts, artistic smart, being a great teacher, carpenter, whatever.. very often those don't make any money, and yet I have met people who do each of those who are absolute geniuses.
- ahlatimer 17y agoPart of being business savvy is working on the right thing. Most artists I know, and some of them are damn fine artists, aren't really working on the right thing because art isn't typically a good way to make a large some of money. Sure, you may end up catching a break and ending up becoming super famous, but that isn't the norm. If those incredibly intelligent people were to direct their interest towards business, my guess is that they'd be more than capable of making money.
- budu3 17y agoI clicked on the link expecting some revealing statistics showing that the smart were getting richer.
- notjeffgoldblum 17y ago[quoted from some website]"It turns out that Mensa has an investment club. Wow. That must be one heck of a way to make money, right? The smartest people in the world making investment decisions. Well, not so fast. During the 15-year period 1986 to 2001, the S&P 500 had average annual returns of 15.3%, but the Mensa investment club's performance averaged returns of just 2.5%. Let's see, that would be 84% worse than the index. How could this be? An amusing article by Eleanor Laise ("If We're So Smart, Why Aren't We Rich?") details the smart-but-undisciplined investment approach that reduced Mensa's returns to fiasco status. In brief, the investing "strategy" of the club relied on trendy tech stocks, horrible timing, and over-reliance on charting. The "strategy" was constantly changed. Some stock picks were taken straight from Internet message boards. One member described the approach as "buy low, sell lower.""[/quote] also: http://minvestmentclub.com/ http://minvestmentclub.com/ sexy web design is sexy
- nazgulnarsil 17y agoI think our society often thinks a person is smart when the person merely came up with a clever new way to be dumb. truly brilliant ideas often get a reaction of "that's dumb" from the general populace. too far outside their scope.
- gaius 17y agoMalcolm Gladwell says, a gifted child is a gifted learner but a gifted adult is a gifted doer and the two are quite different. Mensa members are gifted children who never grew up.