3 ms·
I think you are confusing LEO satellites with micro satellites. The problem of LEO's is that they got an orbit of about 90M which means they stay over a base st
by dogma1138 12y ago
I think you are confusing LEO satellites with micro satellites.
The problem of LEO's is that they got an orbit of about 90M which means they stay over a base station say a small city in Africa for a very short time. In order to provide a constant internet coverage you will need a heck of a allot of them.
This both increases the costs and worse pollute the higher atmosphere with even more orbiting bodies(and derby as they have a life span of < 10 years).
The current launch costs even under best conditions (piggy backing on an existing launch) are between 7000 and 10000 dollars per KG.
There is a reason why no one is currently doing LEO communication satellites and although some projects do exist like the Persistent Communication Network the Pentagon wants to put in they never actually out grew out grew their drafting/project proposal stages.
In fact the biggest opponents of these satellites are the launch providers them selves and NASA even tho these missions are much much more profitable to them.
Using small (100-200KG) LEO communication satellites means 100's of launches over a decade and unlike GEO's the constellation will have to be constantly refreshed due to their short life span.
However they also know that putting so much junk in space without any feasible way of getting (all of it) back to earth is detrimental to the long term space program.
So yeah while universities and even hobbyist groups can launch those cube micro's to space for under 100K it doesn't mean that one of those platforms can be used for a communication satellite they are too small to have any decent power source and don't even have enough space for sufficient transceivers that can provide the amount of bandwidth needed for internet coverage.
LEO also has a very big issue with bandwidth which relates to the fact that the satellite is moving away / towards you at very high speed which means that quite a big chunk of your bandwidth is eaten by the phase correction and tolerance of the signal.
Not to mention having to jump to another bird every couple of minutes will probably also put additional bandwidth, latency and reliability limitations on such network.
But lets say that Elon's new company does managed to some how overcome all these issues and he launches his constellation and now there are 150 cube sats in LEO.
Google then one ups him and launches their constellation, Apple says SIRI now needs to be space born does theirs, Verizion, Comcast/TW, then the US military wakes up and puts their networks, China, Russia, India, EU.
Now you have 1000's of new objects in low earth orbits, with a short time life, almost impossible to track.
Sorry ISS we can't have you up here any more since Africa needs to watch cat videos and we thought it will be cooler if they stream it via OpenHardware cube sats than just putting down fiber optic cables, improving long range terrestrial radio, or using weather balloons or solar drones to give them internet.
- natosaichek 12y agoOne small nitpick - the satellites mentioned are much larger than cubesats - they're talking about a 250 kg satellite - or about 50 times larger than a large 3u cubesat. We're talking mini-fridge sized satellites here, which are much more capable beasts.
- dogma1138 12y ago"Using small (100-200KG) LEO communication satellites means 100's of launches over a decade and unlike GEO's the constellation will have to be constantly refreshed due to their short life span." I understand that cube sats are not a candidate, i some how doubt that 100KG sats are even a candidate. The closest we have so far to non GEO orbit satellites are MEO's like the KA-SAT's and other Ka-Band satellites these orbit at 7500-9000 KM orbits which is about 4 times higher than LEO and they weight 6 tonnes of about half is fuel intended to keep them in orbit for about 15-20 years. Out of those 4 remaining tonnes 3 are used by satellite bus it self which includes the power plant and all "space" components. The payload is under 1000KG and that is barely sufficient to house enough communication equipment to provide about 400Mbit bandwidth. How are they planning on doing the same with something that weight as much as keg i don't know.
- seanflyon 12y agoThe short lifespan in LEO is because there is still a tiny amount of air resistance so the satellites eventually slow down and fall back to earth. This means that space junk can still be a problem in LEO, but only a temporary one and I would not be concerned with a few thousand small boxes in a very large sky.
- dogma1138 12y agoActually junk in LEO is very problematic, you have to pass trough LEO to get any where. LEO is the only feasible placement for permanent/long term special habitats. Junk in LEO tends to have very erratic orbits, and small junk tends to skip on-top of the atmosphere like rocks on the surface of a pond rather than just crash and burn. LEO junk is also much harder to track due to the limited coverage earth based stations have. And i don't know about you but i will be very worried about 100,000's of bullet sized fragments of silicon carbide (the stuff they make brake discs from for high end sports cars) potting used for high end electronics flying around at 30,000 Km/h...