3 ms·
The problem that Reuters faces is that its commenters are essentially trying to grab Reuters' carefully built and maintained megaphone and yell their own stuff.
by jerf 12y ago
The problem that Reuters faces is that its commenters are essentially trying to grab Reuters' carefully built and maintained megaphone and yell their own stuff. There's no way to reconcile the commenter's desires and Reuters desires to not share their megaphone (as such sharing degrades the utility of the megaphone precisely to the extent that the commenters are successful in shouting their own stuff).
There's no "laziness" here, because I'm yet to see even a hint that there is a solution to this problem, despite massive efforts. There's a fundamental conflict of interest. Consequently, commenting on "primary" news sites is uniformly atrocious.
Show me one news site with the reach of Reuters... no, that's hardly fair, show me one news site with a tenth the reach of Reuters that has anything resembling an edifying commentariat.
- Commenttoyou 12y agoNYT
- mixmax 12y agoshow me one news site that has user profiles, a somewhat intelligent voting system and reasonable algorithmic sorting of comments. Most of them haven't even mastered threaded comments yet.
- w1ntermute 12y agoThreaded commenting can be quite challenging/unintuitive to grasp for non-technical users. The problem isn't that it's difficult to implement, it's an issue of UX. It might be fine on HN or reddit, which skew young and tech-savvy, but it's definitely not OK on Facebook. My parents would be lost if faced with threaded comments.
- ultimape 12y agoThis is actually one of the design decisions behind discourse.org - its hotly contested for much of the same reasoning. Expert users 'get' threads quickly, and cant even begin to put themselves in the shoes of an internet newbie.