3 ms·
Lazy? No way. They are right. Comments on news stories never added anything, and publishers only provided comment sections because they thought they "should."
by snowwrestler 12y ago
Lazy? No way. They are right. Comments on news stories never added anything, and publishers only provided comment sections because they thought they "should."
It provided a veneer of user engagement, but how often did reporters or editors participate in comments? How often did reporters change their reporting based on comments? How often did they credit comments in their reporting?
Newspaper comments have been a ghetto for years.
BTW, the same criticisms apply to the comments of most newspaper Facebook pages. Facebook for most publishers is simply a distribution channel--post your stories to your page, hope EdgeRank pushes them into enough user news feeds, and then wait for the traffic to land back on your site. The comments don't matter at all.
The real conversation happens on Facebook when users share the news content--either by re-sharing what Reuters posts, or by sharing it themselves from the website. Then they talk about it with their friends. That's what Reuters is referring to when they say that the best discussion is now in social media. And they are right.
- TeMPOraL 12y ago> Comments on news stories never added anything, and publishers only provided comment sections because they thought they "should." Many news sites do include comment sections on purpose, and from what I heard sometimes even seed them with controversial statements, because they're an excellent way to drive pageviews, and through them, ad money.
- anigbrowl 12y agoYeah, I used to push for comments on newspaper stories back in the early days of the web because I thought it would expand the good things about online discussion forums to encompass a large segment of the public and yield a higher quality of public debate and thus a better quality of democracy. I've gotten more pessimistic since.
- msabalau 12y agoWhat is "lazy" is the assumption that Reuters ought to have comments.