3 ms·
I understand what you're saying and there is merit to your point of view. But, I want the people who pulled the pins on the fake grenades in jail for life. They
by leephillips 12y ago
I understand what you're saying and there is merit to your point of view. But, I want the people who pulled the pins on the fake grenades in jail for life. They attempted mass murder. I don't want them on the street when the only thing preventing them from murdering people is a temporary lack of convenience.
- logfromblammo 12y agoSo how would you deal with the people passing out fake grenades while telling everyone they are real? Would it be any different if they passed out real grenades and said they were fake? Would you support preemptively testing everyone in similar ways, and imprisoning all those who failed? If you described the hypothetical on a paper, and asked people to rate their likelihood of pulling the pin on the imaginary grenade in the imaginary DMV, on a scale from 0 (never) to 10 (always), what numbers would they have to choose to remain free? I, for one, am completely uncomfortable imprisoning people based solely on their psychological profile rather than as punishment for actual harm inflicted in the real world. Some undercover investigations do seem eerily similar to selecting someone based on a profile and then continually testing him until he fails to meet the "stay out of jail" threshold. It just doesn't seem like ethical policing to me.