3 ms·
One advantage of the status quo is that DigiCert won't be issuing certs for "facebookcorehttp.onion" or "facebookrotflbbq.onion" or whatever else you might be a
by geofft 12y ago
One advantage of the status quo is that DigiCert won't be issuing certs for "facebookcorehttp.onion" or "facebookrotflbbq.onion" or whatever else you might be able to brute-force. If they were issuing those certs, it'd be hard to tell if you were on the actual hidden service operated by the entity known to humans as Facebook -- given how ad-hoc the name "facebookcorewwwi.onion" is, the cert isn't making a useful statement the same way a cert for "facebook.com" is.
And that's not even considering the fact that Tor's transport to hidden services implies authenticity... DigiCert is unable to usefully contribute to the claim "these people own facebookcorewwwi.onion" or "these people own facebookrotflbbq.onion" because Tor is already making that claim strongly, so the only claim they can help with is "these people are/aren't who you think of as Facebook".
If DigiCert were able to issue an EV cert for "Facebook, Inc. [US]", that would be another matter entirely, but the industry rules on EV certificates are tight, and in particular I think there are rules about being in the public DNS. I'd imagine one thing they're working on is being able to issue EV certs for .onion domains.