4 ms·
On Being Narrow
- mrshoe 17y agoIn March I was shopping around for a new job. It was common to be asked why I was changing jobs (especially in this economy...). A big part of my answer was that I wanted to try something new. I wanted to make sure that my resume didn't pigeonhole me as a Python web developer. Even though I had been in that field for my first 4 years out of college, I had worked in very different domains previously and I wanted to keep my options open in the future. I enjoy Python web development, but to avoid being too narrow I decided that my next job would be with a different language in a different domain. Most people understood that desire. A recruiter at one company where I interviewed disagreed with the strategy, though. She said it's ok to play around in a few different domains when you're young, but at some point you need to pick one and stick with it. That way you can be seen as expert in that domain and you can be considered eligible for higher level roles with more decision-making responsibility. I suppose I can see her point, but I sincerely hope she's wrong. I want my horizons to always be broad.
- weaksauce 17y agoRegarding the second recruiter, I wouldn't put too much stock in a recruiters opinion. Do whatever you want to do in life and don't worry too much about hitting the "ceiling." If you are on this forum then you probably are above average when it comes to programming and a smart boss would be able to see that programming language experience is secondary to problem solving and personal skills.
- donaq 17y agoInteresting. Why do you think that everyone on this forum is above average when it comes to programming?
- weaksauce 17y agoI definitely did not say everyone. Probably better and everyone on the forum are two different subsets of the same population. That being said, if someone is on this forum they are more likely to be better at programming than average in my opinion. Just giving a shit about what you do is a leg up on a lot of the people out in the world.
- run4yourlives 17y agoShe is dead wrong, with a caveat. Specialists tend to be very attractive to large corporations, where the role is "css designer" or "Oracle database development" or "email administrator". The company can afford the FTE to dedicate to the task with that level of detail, so of course the better you are specialisted, the better will stack up against others. An "oracle database developer" however is useless to a smaller company though, because they can't afford to hire a development team of 200. They need people (for example) that can develop in Oracle, MS SQL and Postgres, and also Python to properly import the data from their latest acquisition. The exposure to different environments and technologies, along with the method of working where you realize you don't know it all, is therefore key. My personal bias is that I find the latter style much more engaging and effective overall. Having worked in both environments, I find generalists much more flexible and in the end, capable, when dealing with things that aren't fully documented or expected. Specialists tend to be very "insular " in their thinking, looking to solve every problem within the scope of their knowledge. If you want to grow in business, however, flexibility is the key. It is simply impossible to know what tomorrow's challenges will be. If you don't think so, go talk to some ColdFusion developers, if you can find them. :-)
- amalcon 17y agoIt's the classic quandary. Think of a term for someone who "does a little of everything". Did you think "jack of all trades"? Did you think "renaissance man"? Did you think something that's neither unambiguously positive nor negative, like "generalist"? A specialist is more valuable when you know exactly what you need someone to do. When you're looking for someone you can just sic on whatever needs help most, you want the generalist. For what it's worth, I'd actively disagree with the recruiter there. A younger person can get a good level of competence in one thing quickly, but one of the most valuable roles is the experienced generalist that everyone can bounce ideas off of. Just having one person like this (and a culture that encourages this) can substantially improve results in many areas on many projects at the same time.
- jacquesm 17y agoThere's a real gem in there: > You'd be surprised how much the tools, models and techniques of one field can apply in another. That goes for anybody, not only for people in academia. I don't know how many times I've profited from being able to apply an idea from a totally unrelated field to software problems. I remember reading the 'simulated annealing' paper long ago and thinking, "wait a minute, if this is possible, what else is possible ?", and I haven't stopped doing that. It's paid off numerous times.
- eswat 17y agoThere's a quote I've lifted from an old comic that I like to repeat to myself every now and then: "specialization breeds weakness" The same can be said about learning a broad range of skills and not excelling in any of them. But for me I've been able to apply more useful ideas from other fields to my core competency than the opposite.
- yarapavan 17y agoSome of the comments make me remind of an Isaiah Berlin’s best known essay in which he distinguishes between two archetypes: the hedgehog and the fox. “The fox knows many things; the hedgehog knows but one.” To paraphrase him in his 1953 essay— The Hedgehog and the Fox: "There is a line among the fragments of the Greek poet Archilochus which says: 'The fox knows many things, but the hedgehog knows one big thing'…[T]aken figuratively, the words can be made to yield a sense in which they mark one of the deepest differences which divide writers and thinkers, and, it may be, human beings in general. For there exists a great chasm between those, on one side, who relate everything to a single central vision, one system less or more coherent or articulate, in terms of which they understand, think and feel — a single, universal, organizing principle in terms of which alone all that they are and say has significance — and, on the other side, those who pursue many ends, often unrelated and even contradictory, connected, if at all, only in some de facto way, for some psychological or physiological cause, related by no moral or aesthetic principle…The first kind of intellectual and artistic personality belongs to the hedgehogs, the second to the foxes." The fox is the generalist, who moves from domain to domain with ease and agility,examining large surface areas, covering wide spaces; the hedgehog is the specialist, who slowly and meticulously delves deeply into the nature of a single domain, uncovering secrets that lie beneath." So who would you want to be? A Hedgehog, who have a single big idea or explanation, or a Fox, which looks for a lot of intersecting causes?
- yarapavan 17y agoJim Collins says: "The fox is complex; the hedgehog simple. And the hedgehog wins."
- run4yourlives 17y agoActually, extending the analogy, evolution shows that generalists tend to be much more successful. It's the reason panda's are endangered and crows dominate most cities.
- xanados 17y agoHumans are the ultimate generalist