10 ms·
On Pins and Needles: Stylist Turns Ancient Hairdo Debate on Its Head (2013)
- aeturnum 12y agoI'm more and more skeptical of historical narratives that portray the knowledge and practices of past peoples as a strict subset of our own knowledge. Along the same lines, we seem to constantly underestimate the peoples of the past (ex: the long-time assumption that the pyramid was built by slave labor[0]). We are absolutely more developed in some areas (sanitation, mechanization), but some things elude us.[1][2][3] [0] http://news.discovery.com/history/ancient-egypt/pyramids-tombs-giza-egypt.htm http://news.discovery.com/history/ancient-egypt/pyramids-tom... [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Damascus_steel http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Damascus_steel [2] http://www.korean-arts.com/about_korean_celadon.htm http://www.korean-arts.com/about_korean_celadon.htm [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_concrete http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_concrete
- tormeh 12y agoIt's true, but we can make way better steel than Damascus steel, nowadays. We are better at almost everything than any past people have ever been. Do you know about anything a past people have done better than we know how today? That would be really fascinating.
- thaumasiotes 12y agoToday we're better at everything, but through history the situation "the people in the past were better at X than we are now" has been quite common.
- keenerd 12y ago> Do you know about anything a past people have done better than we know how today? This is a cheap shot, but preparing laserwort or dodo. More practically, anything that is done by hand and needs a lifetime of training. But you need to be sufficiently specific. No one can use a longbow the way medieval british could, but anyone with a bit of training and a modern compound bow could probably match them. So you'd need to be specific to longbows.
- PhasmaFelis 12y agoI hadn't heard of laserwort. It tickles me that there are (were) actual plants named "rocket" and "laser".
- abecedarius 12y agoThe early Stoics knew propositional logic, and their successors didn't until the mid-19th century. (Source: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/6380918-stoic-logic https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/6380918-stoic-logic) Then the likes of Boole and Frege made it possible to see what they were getting at again from what survived -- which was, mainly, hostile reviews. Until then, anyone would've told you the current theory of logic was as advanced as it'd ever been, and the Stoics were guilty of arid pettifogging. One thing Mates does in the book I mentioned is find translators' misunderstandings and prejudices, like the hair-sewing bit in the OP. That also comes up in Lucio Russo's The Forgotten Revolution about the sources on Hellenistic science -- classicists generally aren't scientists either. (This comment is turning out to sound really hard on classicists, and I certainly don't feel that way. I'm just an interested reader.)
- rajat 12y agoAt least one form of Roman concrete was better than anything we moderns had been able to come up with until we rediscovered the formula a few years ago. Link: http://borepatch.blogspot.com/2013/06/long-lost-roman-concrete-formula.html http://borepatch.blogspot.com/2013/06/long-lost-roman-concre...
- ableal 12y agoI'm reminded of the "Rem acu tetigisti" that P.G.Wodehouse would have Bertie Wooster and Jeeves toss out on some occasions.
- bane 12y agoI've followed Ms. Stephens' work off and on since I found out about her research, even submitted a few videos she's produced showing the technique here on HN. It's absolutely fascinating and there's something really immediate and connecting about her work. She also does a wonderful job documenting her work and assumptions and should be given honorary letters from some institute that cares. Strangely enough, not too long before I found out about her, I was in a museum looking at Roman busts and also found a similar fascination with the hairstyles. Stone doesn't really capture the detail of hair, but it struck me that there was real identifiable fashion in the hairstyles being worn (as opposed to hair being styled to show tribal or ancestral membership). I looked around for a little bit on the web but there's really pitifully little we know about this kind of day-to-day minutia, and it's that kind of stuff that really brings the past alive with me.
- codezero 12y agoYeah, there is a huge dearth in the day to day lives of average people throughout history. This sounds really stupid, but I am still generally vexed as to how people, say, 500 or a thousand years ago managed to get their first outfit. If you're barely scraping by a living, how can you afford hand made items like clothing, which requires precious natural resources and time to create. Those outfits must have had to last a very long time as well, what did they look like, what was the total flow of the transaction? How did the weaver get the raw materials? Was it all exchange based? I'll make you a shirt if you give me enough material to make two? Considering a lot of people didn't own the land or crops they farmed, how did the workers get the money or raw materials to obtain something as simple as a shirt, especially if they were, say, 8 years old. Anyhow, I'm rambling a bit. It's really easy to take for granted a simple thing like your shirt :)
- johnny99 12y agoIt wasn't 500 years ago, but homesteaders similarly had to make from scratch most of what they wore, and used, and ate. I've been reading the Laura Ingalls Wilder books with my daughter, and Wilder goes into quite a bit of detail about all the very many things her family had to be able to do themselves, using only raw materials. In general, everyone in the family is absolutely always working, and they all have a wealth of craft knowledge which had been passed down through the family. Extended families and neighbors work together when many hands are needed. They're kid's books, but really interesting nonetheless.
- soperj 12y agoThis is the kind of thing that keeps me coming back here. I'm sure someone will eventually ask "why is this on hn", but for me this is the really cool stuff that I come to HN every day hoping to find.
- comrh 12y agoHearing about someone get so into a arguably esoteric subject and really expand the knowledge base is inspiring.