4 ms·
That's horrible advice. Tax decisions should never drive business decisions until the amount of tax actually becomes a material financial statement item. If you
by gamblor956 12y ago
That's horrible advice. Tax decisions should never drive business decisions until the amount of tax actually becomes a material financial statement item. If you let tax effects drive your business decisions as a startup, you end up with a structure more complicated than the most efficient option, and most of the future tax "savings" disappear to lost opportunities or maintenance of your "optimized" structure.
(not to mention the negative effects of CA's business income tax, higher payroll taxes, office rents, living expenses for employees, etc. on your valuation).
Nevada hasn't turned out so well for the many startups who have moved there. Check out re/code's entire series of the Downtown Vegas experiment. It turns out that money isn't everything, or even the most important thing. If your business couldn't succeed in California, moving to Nevada won't make a difference.
Mark Zuckerberg alone has paid a multi-billion dollar penalty for the mere privilege of living in California.
Zuckerberg chose to pay a lot of taxes for the privilege of living in California, the state which made it possible for him to earn many billions of dollars. Without Silicon Valley, nobody would remember or care about Zuckerberg today. (Even Zappos, Nevada's only success story to date, found its initial success in California.) Zuckerberg did the right thing: he paid it forward so that California could continue to be the place where people go to make it big.
- downandout 12y agoNevada hasn't turned out so well for the many startups who have moved there. Bad companies and/or ideas will fail anywhere, and they will fail faster in high burn rate areas like the Valley. Good (internet) companies will succeed anywhere. When was the last time you refused to install an app based upon where the company behind it was based? Tax decisions should never drive business decisions until the amount of tax actually becomes a material financial statement item. Nonsense. You should plan for failure, but you should also plan for success. Without Silicon Valley, nobody would remember or care about Zuckerberg today. Also nonsense. Facebook was a great, viral product. No one cared, cares, and in the beginning, even knew, where it was based (and it didn't start in the Valley either).
- 7Figures2Commas 12y ago> That's horrible advice. Tax decisions should never drive business decisions until the amount of tax actually becomes a material financial statement item. If you let tax effects drive your business decisions as a startup, you end up with a structure more complicated than the most efficient option, and most of the future tax "savings" disappear to lost opportunities or maintenance of your "optimized" structure. Tax considerations should never be the sole driver of business decisions but that isn't a good justification for ignoring them. Founders, for instance, should know about 83(b) elections and Qualified Small Business Stock (QSBS). Incidentally, California is one of the few states in which the exclusion of gains from the sale of QSBS is not allowed. I would venture a guess that close to 100% of tech startup founders today have no idea what QSBS is even though it can allow them to eliminate up to 50% of their capital gains tax when they sell their company. Your comment seems to be based on the flawed assumption that legitimate tax planning involves complicated corporate structures. There's nothing complicated or expensive about choosing to reside in Nevada (because of the lower costs, business-friendly environment, etc.) and structuring your Nevada-based business as a Nevada corporation. That is far less complicated and expensive than, for instance, choosing to reside in California and structuring your California-based business as a Delaware corporation, which is something that a ton of California startups do based on the hopeful assumption that they're going to raise capital from investors who will require Delaware incorporation. > Nevada hasn't turned out so well for the many startups who have moved there. California isn't a panacea for startups either. For every Facebook, there are countless ventures that never took off. Startups fail at a very high rate. Wherever they're located.