4 ms·
Anyone got any ideas on how governments could effectively clamp down on this? In Australia, IKEA paid 1%* tax over the last 12 years, even as sales surged 500%
by prawn 12y ago
Anyone got any ideas on how governments could effectively clamp down on this?
In Australia, IKEA paid 1%* tax over the last 12 years, even as sales surged 500%:
http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/nov/06/luxembourg-tax-leaks-put-pressure-on-g20-leaders-to-act-on-loopholes http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/nov/06/luxembourg-tax-...
(The Guardian article has since removed the 1% reference, though it was in there when I first read the article.)
- return0 12y agoFirst you need to communicate this to the public and show that the problem is only going to get worse, as globalization allows more and more elaborate schemes like this. This will justify lowering corporate taxes, or establishing official authorities that will negotiate special tax deals with companies. In short, what luxembourg is doing, all big countries will be doing soon as well.
- lumberjack 12y agoI would understand how small countries would have a hard time dealing with big corps but could not a big country just tell them to close shop and go elsewhere if it deems them to be evading taxes? Probably some kind of FTA forbids his but in principle it should work, shouldn't it? After all countries are supposed to be sovereign entities.
- xgbi 12y agoProblem is, in regard of European laws, you can't tell them to fuck off if they are not doing anything unlawful. And here it is the case, they exploit a hole in the law which allows to create subsidiaries in Luxembourg through which the French/German/whatever company is paying the products it sells.
- mike_hearn 12y agoThe hole in the law is not really a hole, it's designed to work like that. The EU single market was created to simplify trade across borders in Europe, because that makes everyone wealthier. Imagine if every country had to make everything itself! Tax is a big part of what makes trade complicated. If you had to file taxes in dozens of different languages, dozens of times, each year to every EU country, it'd be much harder to sell across the single market. So the EU does not require that, you can incorporate once and sell to the whole market. That means, you get to pick where in the EU you incorporate, and as different regions have different levels of taxation .... well, it's no different to freedom of movement for individuals. They can go live somewhere with lower taxes if they want to. The places they didn't choose to live might not like that, but you can't have both simplicity and every government getting to tax everyone else.
- higherpurpose 12y agoI'm not saying I condone it (I especially don't like the part of routing all of your profits made in other countries through a single country with lower taxes, and don't think it's fair) - but maybe there's an argument to be made about low income tax for corporations, if that actually leads to much higher sales (on which consumers pay VAT, so tax money still goes to the government)?
- pfortuny 12y agoThe quesution is.... and what about small businesses? Why should they be treated differently than corps?
- ams6110 12y agoLower tax rates, and simpler tax rules, often lead to higher revenues. Make it easy to comply with the rules, set reasonable rates, and companies may find it easier to deal with than setting up shell offices in another country and employing teams of accountants and lawyers and bankers to shuffle the money around.
- lsaferite 12y agoOr, no income tax at all and just a sales/use tax across the board.
- Shivetya 12y agoTax the sale of the item to the end buyer and do away with all corporate taxes? That would be easiest method but psychologically it may cause angst amount the populace when they realize just how much tax they pay on everyday purchases. going back to other stories, if and when space tourism takes off, whats to stop someone from relocating to orbit and avoiding excessive and at times abusive taxation?
- lsaferite 12y agoI personally like the idea of dropping income taxes and switching to just sales/use tax. Compliance is simplified, tax codes are simplified, and tax avoidance is reduced. There are many practical aspect that would need to be resolved, like how do you apply this to imports and such, but those are solvable problems.
- mike_hearn 12y agoMost countries use VAT rather than sales tax, which is generally agreed by people who specialise in tax incidence to be better, but comes with its own interesting forms of evasion (see "carousel fraud"). Phasing out corporation tax entirely would be impossible for most countries to do quickly because such a huge part of their budgets come from that. In the UK it's about 25% I believe and the government there is still spending far, far more than it takes in via tax, so losing 25% of that revenue is a non-starter, and making it up with higher personal income taxes would be politically impossible: even if you could prove mathematically it was equivalent or better to do that, people feel very strongly that there exists an "us vs them" relationship between people and companies, where "us" often includes the government. This is despite that most people work for companies, and there's lots of evidence governments should sometimes be in the "them" bucket. I don't really know where societies go from here with corporation tax - there are so many good arguments against it, but it's sort of like trying to give up smoking. You can argue all you want but lots of countries just aren't going to do it. The first step would be to get western state finances more balanced though. Once governments aren't ballooning their debt, more complex arguments about taxation become possible to make. Whilst they're all spiralling the drain it's too hard.
- jdimov 12y agoThere is only one correct solution - abolish all taxation based on profits.