12 ms·
The article it is referencing is this one: https://openstandard.mozilla.org/yes-gamergate-is-a-ed-tech-issue/ https://openstandard.mozilla.org/yes-gamergate-is
by bhouston 12y ago
The article it is referencing is this one:
https://openstandard.mozilla.org/yes-gamergate-is-a-ed-tech-issue/ https://openstandard.mozilla.org/yes-gamergate-is-a-ed-tech-...
Why he didn't link directly to it in the apologies is a bit weird.
Also I do not completely understand what the apology is about, for this article? For other formal responses to it? (Where are they btw?) For the contents of the comment sections on these articles?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- davidgerard 12y agoMozilla takes editorial responsibility for everything on Open Standard (which is why a lot of people internally thought OS was a terrible idea), and @firefox just tweeted the new article approvingly.
- huehue 12y agoMy brain stopped after "meritocracy misogyny".
- untog 12y agoWhy? Do you genuinely believe that tech is purely meritocratic?
- aikah 12y agoThey touched something that is highly toxic and it was a mistake.This is something which HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH TECH. That's why apologies are justified,I'm glad Mozilla is setting the record straight. I dont want to hear about that gamergate stuff.If people want to fight,let them go on twitter,youtube or on msnbc to make a fool out of themself.
- knowtheory 12y ago1) Mozilla's stated mission is an Open Web. Any society has culture, and technology certainly does. Deciding not to talk about culture is a cultural choice. 2) Ignoring GamerGate is basically tacit approval. It's a banner used to harass people over the flimsiest and stupidest of reasons. You can stick your fingers in your ears and ignore it if you want. That's kind of a shitty move but ultimately your prerogative. But to say that nobody should talk about it because you don't want to hear about it? Who says that's your decision to make? Edit for replies: Ignoring harassment of others doesn't make it go away. In fact all it does is allow harassment to go unchallenged. I don't expect people to go actively confront people on whether they think gamergate is dumb or not, but if your position is "i don't want to talk about it" or "i don't know, maybe both sides have good points" then you need to reexamine what you think living together what other human beings means. Gamergate is a fucking stupid reason to harass anybody. Anybody who is neutral or pro-gamergate needs to contend with that fact.
- Someone1234 12y ago> Ignoring GamerGate is basically tacit approval What utter twaddle.
- aikah 12y ago> Ignoring GamerGate is basically tacit approval. You know guys,that's exactly why some people dont want to hear about that stuff,because of people like you saying insane things like that.
- untog 12y agoWhen it reaches the point where death threats are being issued against people, I personally do want to hear about Gamergate stuff.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- notjackma 12y ago> This is something which HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH TECH. THIS. You get my upvote. This is what is wrong with Mozilla and it was exposed for all to see when they forced Brendan Eich out over a political donation he made years ago. Too many people at Mozilla are spending their time as social activists instead of working on technology. They are bringing their own personal beliefs to work and in the process ruining Mozilla. Perhaps the first line of the employee handbook should read: "Open Web" != "Social Justice".
- steveklabnik 12y agoThat article was not the one that made everyone upset. https://openstandard.mozilla.org/yes-gamergate-is-everyones-issue/ https://openstandard.mozilla.org/yes-gamergate-is-everyones-... Was the article that made everyone upset. Well, also, @firefox tweeting the story you linked to with the #gamergate hashtag brought a whole world of bullshit down on Audrey, so there's that. This is why the 'apology' talks about 'starting a conversation,' because it was two articles _and_ a number of other tweets by @firefox, positioning #gamergate as a 'conversation' and 'controversy' between two equal sides, rather than a weirdly obsessive harassment campaign with a cover story.
- tomp 12y agoWait, I don't get it... The apology mentions an article by "Audrey Watters", which is the article mentioned by your parent [1]. However, you mention another article [2], which was apparently "more upsetting" (personally, I see both articles as basically saying people should not be getting death threats), written by "Georgina Young". So which one is it? Or maybe both, or the mention of a controversial topic itself?
- commandar 12y agoWell, and there you have exactly why this topic is so toxic. Everyone is so convinced they're right that they're more interested in digging in and painting caricatures of each other than actually having a discussion. At this point, there's no way for anything constructive to happen with the valid concerns either side of this has because all the focus is on the worst elements of all involved.