69 ms·
It's clear from your multiple posts in this thread that you have some sort of star-eyes for Jobs, and nothing I say will persuade you otherwise. With that said
by Alupis 12y ago
It's clear from your multiple posts in this thread that you have some sort of star-eyes for Jobs, and nothing I say will persuade you otherwise.
With that said, I do feel you are giving awfully too much credit to someone who never actually designed anything in his life. Sure, he was at the helm of each of the companies that ended up producing good results, but do you actually believe Jobs himself was directly involved in the day-to-day decisions and engineering of each of the products? Absolutely not, he's busy running the company. The true unsung hero's at Apple and NeXT were the engineers, and their direct management team. Jobs may have been good at assembling a good management team and motivating them, but the management team are the ones who are good at assembling the right engineering team with the right motivation. I mean, Jony Ive should get more credit than Jobs for the iPhone, because he was and is the end-all-be-all of design for the product. Who recruited him? Not Jobs, it was Brunner.
Was Jobs great? Sure. Was he any more great than any of the modern great tech CEO's (Bill Gates, Eric Schmidt, Larry Ellison, Jonathan Schwartz, etc...)? Nope.
(btw, it's still 7% even in 1973 dollars. Jobs took home 93% without doing a thing while Woz got no credit, and no profit)
- astrodust 12y agoComparing Steve Jobs to Larry Ellison is ridiculous, so it's obvious you've got no idea what you're talking about or you're de-valuing the role of a founder/executive to the point where they're just some figurehead. Jobs built both Apple and Pixar, two companies with enormous influence in their respective fields. Those companies have organizational structures that are radically different, each one optimized towards their business and core ethos. Ellison built Oracle, an interchangeable enterprise software company, and a World Cup team. Impressive but not nearly the same league.
- Alupis 12y agoA nit-pick -- Jobs bought Pixar, then let them do their thing with minimal oversight. Pixar was great because they were great. They just needed funding. > Ellison built Oracle, an interchangeable enterprise software company You may view Oracle as simply interchangeable and expendable, but in their respective space they dominate. They don't sell "sexy" products to consumers no, but as we've seen with all consumer-faced companies -- their time comes and goes -- while enterprise is constant. Do you even know Ellison's story? It's far more inspirational than most other tech titan CEO's. It's the rags to riches story, and now he owns an island, world class sailing team, one of the world's largest yachts, and one of the largest enterprise-space companies in the world. Really the cliche "American Dream"
- melling 12y agoJust another nick-pick. You're wrong here too. Jobs created Pixar: http://alvyray.com/Pixar/PixarMyth1.htm http://alvyray.com/Pixar/PixarMyth1.htm "A new spinout corporation from Lucasfilm, called Pixar, was capitalized with $10 million from Steve Jobs." "Eventually, by about 1991, he owned 100% of Pixar at a total investment of $50 million." And Jobs was the CEO of Pixar. By the way, my facts are from one of the co-founders of Pixar: http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alvy_Ray_Smith http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alvy_Ray_Smith I suppose we don't give Bill Gates credit for his foundation either? Everyone else is doing all the work. It's just his vision and money.
- Alupis 12y agoIt's funny how you pick and chose parts of history to make your point. Jobs did not found Pixar -- he bought the company (under a different name then changed to Pixar) from Lucas Film. He was not the CEO, he was chairman of the board and famously had very little to do with their day-to-day activities -- he really just let them do their thing. He almost sold Pixar multiple times because they were not the home-run company he had hope for, until Toy Story. He slowly bought shares back from employees and the actual founders until he owned almost 100% of the company (making his total investment $50 million). Then he sold the company off to Disney. Jobs was the check book for Pixar -- he didn't make them great, they were great all along. They just had no product and no capital for a long period of time. He gave them the chance to succeed, and for that he should get credit. But he wasn't some sort of creative mastermind genius that turned Pixar into what is became. In any regard, we've gone into the weeds. As I said multiple posts ago, I'm never going to change your mind. Apple sold products you like as a consumer, and therefore you like the person at the helm. Personally, I think there are far better businessman examples all over, some I've mentioned already, others are like the guy in Napa Valley, CA making $2 billion a year selling wine corks.
- melling 12y agoSteve was someone I threw out as a person who had multiple acts. I threw out Elon as an example on this page too. We are not trying to solve who the best business man is? After all, what would any of that have to do with the Woz? If you want to compare a $2 billion business to one of the most valuable companies in the world, we could be here all day. By the way, I based my claim that Jobs was CEO of Pixar based on the co-founder of Pixar, and other facts I found on the Internet. Can you provide some facts to show that I'm wrong? http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alvy_Ray_Smith http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alvy_Ray_Smith http://alvyray.com/Pixar/PixarMyth1.htm http://alvyray.com/Pixar/PixarMyth1.htm
- melling 12y agoNo one is trying to raise anyone to Sainthood here. However, Jobs certainly had enough repeated success that it's really hard to say that he just got lucky. I certainly wouldn't put Eric Schmidt and Jonathan Schwartz in the same category; Sun was sold for less than Skype. Larry and Bill definitely ran great companies. And Bill does have a second act. He's trying to change the world on a larger scale. Good for him, and the world. Anyway, you're still missing the point. Caught in some endless loop. Your version of Mighty Mouse vs Superman. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dxNidpRNA0g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dxNidpRNA0g