4 ms·
It would do no harm you say? Consider what it would actually take to make this work. There would have to be a standard of labeling, there would have to be laws,
by InclinedPlane 17y ago
It would do no harm you say? Consider what it would actually take to make this work. There would have to be a standard of labeling, there would have to be laws, there would have to be consequences for not following the law. There would need to be efforts expended to police those laws.
This translates into the government spending money, which comes out of tax payer pockets, or public debt, or decreased spending on USEFUL public works. None of these are good things.
This also translates into greater reach of the state into everyone's business. What happens if some small-time 'zine writer fails to comply with the law? Do they get fined, hassled, thrown into jail? How do we prevent abuses of power in enforcing these laws? Perhaps some enforcement agent closes down a news outlet they don't like with false claims they are breaking this law.
All of these things are very real concerns, even for such a simple law as this one. And ultimately what you end up with is greater power in the hands of the state and an ever increasing infantilization and disempowerment of the individual.
This, I put forth, represents harm.
- foldr 17y agoOn the other hand, spending time and money on this sort of relatively harmless government scheme just means that there is less time for the government to do all the other sinister and terrifying things that it was planning on doing, no? So from the position of someone who is worried about increasing state power, it seems to me that you could argue it both ways. > I put forth You "put forth", seriously?