3 ms·
On election day, consider abstaining from ignorant voting
- varelse 12y agoI'll take an uninformed off the cuff vote over the abstention of a depressed slacktivist any day, but maybe that's just me. If voters are voting ignorantly, then let the politicians spend more time informing them rather than slinging mud at each other. Oh excuse me, I mean hey check out that boat full of cocaine owned by Mitch McConnell's in-laws because scandal!
- imgabe 12y agoI don't agree with this. There are a number of races I voted in more or less randomly today, and I feel perfectly fine about that. I look at it this way. There is, we can assume, one "optimal" candidate. We have little way of knowing which one this will be until after they're elected and have started working. In some cases there may be candidates who are very obviously non-optimal - like if they're currently being indicted - but aside from that, it's tough to tell. If I know nothing, the chance that I'll vote for that candidate is 1/N where N is the number of candidates. If I do know about the race, and have been persuaded to vote for a non-optimal candidate, there's 0% chance that I'll vote for the optimal outcome. The only situation where my vote definitely contributes to a good outcome is if I know for sure that the candidate is the best one, but that requires predicting the future, and is impossible. There will always be a pretty good chance my vote could have been cast for someone better. I think in the end, the probability that the best candidate gets elected in low-information races is going to tend towards 1/N anyway, so you may as well increase the sample size.
- jordanpg 12y ago> Even if you are an unusually well-informed voter, the enormous size, scope, and complexity of modern government ensure that there will be many issues and candidates about which you know very little…. This argument can be used ad infinitum. There cannot be such a thing as perfectly informed about anything that has subjective components, so this doesn't sway me. I find a corollary of this much more interesting: in elections for office -- as opposed to referenda -- I find that the amount of information I need to make a binary choice is often trivial. I absolutely cannot understand why there are so many millions of people out there who have such a hard time making up their mind on these things. Moreover, we have the gift of information about candidates at our fingertips. Maybe others see subtleties where I see rather stark contrasts, but I doubt it. I think it's all just political news reporting-generated false churn.