4 ms·
US price levels 1665 to 2005, with 2005 = 100
- indiejade 17y agoHypothesis: possible partial cause of the sudden spike ~ 1945 - 1960 where the graph takes off: Introduction of television into mainstream society. Fueled by advertising, everything "costs" more: entertainment is fueled by advertising. News is also fueled by advertising. Advertising places a new layer of "value" on products, causing the sudden perceived need to pay more. Interesting data.
- cperciva 17y agoThe graph "takes off" where it does because economists figured out that deflation harms the economy by encouraging irrational hoarding of money. Modern central banks aim to keep inflation predictable, low, and positive; several banks have explicit targets (usually 2%) which are chosen largely by asking the question "given that inflation rates have inherent volatility, what's the lowest average inflation rate we can have without volatility regularly pushing it below zero?"
- indiejade 17y agoThis is true; regarding this specific time period, however, there were definitely some large historical events that contributed to prices rising. The logarithmic scale reveals it as well. Vietnam, yes, but also that whole patriotism thing, news reporting, and "Buy American" which was, obviously, fueled by the birth of the advertising age.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- pg 17y agoThis graph seems off to me. I have a hard time believing the 80 years from 1665 to 1745 were a period of constant deflation.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- cperciva 17y agoIf you look carefully, it's not constant deflation in that period -- over those 80 years there's an average deflation rate of 0.6%, but at many points the price index jumps 10% above the trendline. I find these numbers to be entirely believable -- after all, this is a period when the American Colonies are expanding rapidly, with resulting effects in terms of specialization of skills and self-sufficiency. It's going to be far cheaper to have something produced in 1745 by the local expert X-maker than it was to import the same item from Britain in 1665.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- ivankirigin 17y agoBoy is that not the story here. It's what happens after WWII. There is pretty much no measure of currency that will change this basic story, which has two parts: USD as a reserve currency post Bretton Woods, and abandoning the gold standard giving notes no intrinsic value.
- barrkel 17y agoGold has no intrinsic value either; its value is barter value, what other people believe it's worth. Fiat money is no different; its value is barter value, what other people think it's worth, which includes how much they trust the issuer not to debase it.
- mbrubeck 17y agoHere's the same graph with a logarithmic scale, which is better for comparing rates of change across time: http://oregonstate.edu/cla/polisci/faculty-research/sahr/pll1665.htm http://oregonstate.edu/cla/polisci/faculty-research/sahr/pll... And here's the source of both graphs, with links to raw data and more figures: http://oregonstate.edu/cla/polisci/faculty-research/sahr/sahr.htm http://oregonstate.edu/cla/polisci/faculty-research/sahr/sah...
- quantumhobbit 17y agoThanks for that. Inflation is a cumulative effect and makes a lot more sense on a log scale. Interesting to note that the rate of inflation during the civil war dwarfs anything else, which is what one would expect. I also noticed that there was a huge amount of inflation prior to the Great Depression. The post WWII era is interesting not for the huge amount of inflation but the absence of any deflation.
- thras 17y agoNo, that's not a graph of inflation rate. That's a graph of price levels. It's not cumulative.
- mbrubeck 17y agoThe derivative of the price level (i.e. the slope on these charts) is the inflation rate. The slope on the log-scale chart corresponds to the inflation rate in percentages, which is meaningful. The slope on the linear-scale chart is the inflation rate in "dollars per year" which is not. That's why the log-scale chart is more useful for comparing inflation rates over time.
- thras 17y agoYes, the derivative is the inflation rate. If we want to talk about that, why not look at a graph of that instead? And assuming we can't for some bizarre reason, the log graph is better at comparing inflation rates, huh? So in which graph do you spot the 1665 to 1945 price stability first?
- Kadin 17y agoI don't quite get it. What is this data based on? What goods are included? The price of food, for instance, has fallen dramatically just in the past 50-75 years. In both percent-of-household-budget and real dollar terms, it's dirt cheap compared to what it used to be. So any CPI-type "basket" that includes food ought to show price deflation over time. In the meantime, many things that would have been unthinkable luxuries have become regarded as necessities of one sort or another. I suspect the average number of square feet of living space has gone up dramatically, as has energy consumption. But to just factor that into "price" doesn't seem particularly fair, since the 'average' standard of living in 2005 is so much higher than in 1795. The chart is neat but it needs more context.
- bps4484 17y agoI completely agree, except for the last line. This chart is worthless without any details as to how the numbers are calculated.
- jibiki 17y ago> and real dollar terms What does that mean? Obviously, you need more US dollars today to purchase food than you did in 1950, due to inflation. Does "real dollar terms" mean adjusted for inflation? http://www.gti.net/mocolib1//prices/1950.html http://www.gti.net/mocolib1//prices/1950.html 1950: Beef is $.43/lb http://www.gti.net/mocolib1//prices/2009.html http://www.gti.net/mocolib1//prices/2009.html 2009: Beef is $2.99/lb
- m_eiman 17y ago"real dollars" means something like "percentage of disposable income". Also it's impossible to make a meaningful comparison of things you buy for money today compared to things that were bought for money two hundred years ago. Back then a lot more people grew their own food, for example. And they didn't work for software startups and buy all their tech equipment from minimum wage factories in China.
- Kadin 17y agoYes, basically. "Real dollars" are dollars adjusted for inflation. I think it's a little more precise than just saying "inflation-adjusted dollars" because when people hear that, they automatically assume "adjusted using CPI," which is only one way to try and correct for inflation. It's a reasonably well-accepted way, but there are others. (E.g.: labor-hours are popular in some circles.) Cf. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real_versus_nominal_value_%28economics%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real_versus_nominal_value_%28ec...
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- jerf 17y agoIs this supposed to be proving any sort of a point? Serious question; what's the point here?
- yanowitz 17y agoI made an interactive version of the chart with his later data (that now starts in 1774) here http://verifiable.com/charts/3937 http://verifiable.com/charts/3937 (I also added the log version so you can compare them)