3 ms·
> It appears that the current quantum mechanical view of the world is simply an acknowledgement of this complexity and the associated unknowns. While it present
by amluto 12y ago
> It appears that the current quantum mechanical view of the world is simply an acknowledgement of this complexity and the associated unknowns. While it presents a statistical "model" that works for our purposes, it must be acknowledged as a model and not confused with reality. The push for figuring out what drives the statistics needs to continue beyond the building of a model.
This is not a accurate representation of quantum mechanics.
If you were to write down a classical description of the state of all the particles in a piece of paper and the state of all the particles that they might interact with over the course of a few seconds, and you solved the equations for what happens, you would get an exact description of the result. This description would be wrong if you look closely enough because classical mechanism doesn't correctly describe the universe we live in.
If you did the same thing with a quantum description of the initial state of the paper, you would also get an exact description of the result. That description would be very strange -- if try to deduce what you would see if you looked at the piece of paper (remember, you're just a bunch more particles interacting with that paper), you learn the bizarre answer that you would seem to have some chance of seeing the paper in one configuration and some chance of seeing the paper in a different configuration.
But there's no respect in which quantum mechanics is an acknowledgement of some kind of complexity that is beyond our computational ability to describe exactly. To the contrary, quantum mechanics is our attempt to describe things exactly, and it works amazingly well.
It's certainly true that a full quantum description of all but the smallest systems is far beyond our ability to compute directly. That's when we switch to statistical mechanics or similar techniques to try to deal with the complexity in a manageable way.
To the pedants: if you're trying to model a piece of paper with quantum mechanics, then you'll have to approximate the very small-scale high-energy bits, because we don't know the laws of physics at those scales. But there is so far no compelling reason to believe that those laws will not fit perfectly in the framework of quantum mechanics once we figure them out.
- msravi 12y ago> you learn the bizarre answer that you would seem to have some chance of seeing the paper in one configuration and some chance of seeing the paper in a different configuration And so why couldn't there be an underlying parameter that determines that chance of which configuration you will see the paper in? > But there's no respect in which quantum mechanics is an acknowledgement of some kind of complexity that is beyond our computational ability to describe exactly. I certainly didn't mean that we are limited by our computational ability. What I meant (if it wasn't clear) was that we currently lack the understanding of these unknown parameters and their interactions
- 4ad 12y ago> And so why couldn't there be an underlying parameter that determines that chance of which configuration you will see the paper in? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell's_theorem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell's_theorem
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- matt_kantor 12y agomsravi didn't mention anything about this hypothetical parameter being local. Bell's theorem does not rule out nonlocal hidden variables. See also http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loopholes_in_Bell_test_experiments http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loopholes_in_Bell_test_experime.... Many of these are practical matters and have been overcome in one experiment or another, but some issues (like the possibility of superdeterminism) are more fundamental. And the article explicitly mentions how pilot waves through superfluids could give rise to nonlocal yet deterministic effects.
- pmoriarty 12y ago"remember, you're just a bunch more particles interacting with that paper" Very controversial statement.