3 ms·
> ...pilot wave theory--which is taught in every introductory QM course and covered in every introductory QM text... Having assisted in teaching intro QM cours
by jessriedel 12y ago
> ...pilot wave theory--which is taught in every introductory QM course and covered in every introductory QM text...
Having assisted in teaching intro QM courses, I can say this is very incorrect -- unless you replace "every" with "many" and "taught/covered" with "mentioned off hand".
I just pulled the very popular "introduction to quantum mechanics" by Griffiths off my shelf. It contains nothing about pilot waves except for a single footnote in an appendix used as an example of "a number of hidden variable theories [proposed over the years]".
- tjradcliffe 12y agoOK, "every GOOD intro QM course" and "every GOOD intro QM text" :-) I shall now walk away mumbling about the degenerate state of today's youth...
- Osmium 12y agoGriffiths happens to be the most accessible while-still-rigorous QM book I've read, so I'd be careful with the criticism ;) it is concise though, which is probably the main reason it doesn't really discuss pilot waves.
- TTPrograms 12y agoA book not containing a fringe, weak theory does not make it bad.
- vanderZwan 12y agoSure thing, True Scotsman ;)
- cshimmin 12y agoAgreed... I managed to finished all my courses towards a PhD in high-energy physics without ever having heard of pilot wave theory before. I'm an experimentalist but we still have to take all the same standard QM/QFT courses as the theory guys.