3 ms·
>The government does not have the power to make me happy, in any useful sense of the term power. I'm not sure what you mean here. It certainly doesn't have the
by foldr 17y ago
>The government does not have the power to make me happy, in any useful sense of the term power.
I'm not sure what you mean here. It certainly doesn't have the power to guarantee your happiness under all conceivable circumstances (and neither do you, and nor does any other entity) but it can certainly make decisions which either increase or decrease your happiness. You would be happier, I assume, if the government decided to cut your taxes, and less happy if it decided to increase them. (Or pick some other example if that particular one doesn't work for you.)
>The article's point is once you start arguing against the preceding two paragraphs, you really ought to be aware that you just threw liberty out the window
This is the alarmist part. Efforts on the part of a government to make its citizens happy do not necessarily entail "throwing liberty out of the window". This is simply nonsense. And in general, saying that anyone who fails to agree with your "preceding two paragraphs" is inherently opposed to liberty is a rather childish rhetorical tactic.
>The only way the government can make you happy is to exert an awful lot of control,
Governments do all sorts of things (e.g. running the legal system, maintaining basic regulations on the market) which tend, on the whole, to increase levels of happiness. I don't know if this counts as an "awful lot" of control, but it doesn't seem especially unjustified or sinister. Neither does the particular form of control in the case at issue, which is nothing more than a minor market regulation of an unremarkable sort. You are talking as if the aim here was for the government to somehow guarantee the happiness of every citizen, but of course no-one is proposing that it either could be or should be so. Some people do think that in those cases where a government policy may reasonably be expected to increase people's general well-being, it might, typically, absent reasons to the contrary, be a good idea to enact that policy. But this sort of moderate position is of course too radically pro-statist for the doom-and-gloom libertarians.
>I'm also reacting much more to the British thing
What's the "British thing"?
>That is to say, this is a feel-good measure for the lawmaker, I don't see how it will actually change anything.
If it's not going to change anything, what is there to get so upset about? I suppose it is a good chance to jump on the usual "gub'mint outa my 'shop" bandwagon.
- jerf 17y ago"Governments do all sorts of things (e.g. running the legal system, maintaining basic regulations on the market) which tend, on the whole, to increase levels of happiness." You seem to have missed or not understood the point about protecting my right to pursue happiness. This entails things like keeping the criminal justice system working, and a military sufficient to defend the country. Everything you outline except taxes fits into that framework. Where things go off the rail is when "the ability to pursue happiness" as a metric for goodness is replaced by "happiness" as a metric for goodness. This is not the same thing at all. Once you permit that as an argument for letting (or requiring) the government to do something, you're in a different domain. Taxes is an example of government making me less happy. You speak as if the government by default owns all my money, and I should be happy about what I am graciously permitted to keep. No, I am unhappy about what they take. I acknowledge the need for it, but it would be fairly odd if it made me happy. Failing to make me less unhappy is perhaps in some sense increasing my happiness, but I'm not ready to accord them much credit for that action, in the hypothetical world in which my taxes might go down anytime soon.
- foldr 17y ago>Everything you outline except taxes fits into that framework. You have missed my point, which is that governments do indeed have the power to both increase and decrease your happiness. Your contention appears to be that they do not have the power to increase happiness but only to decrease it (or perhaps, at best, fail to decrease it). This contention is what I'm arguing against. I am not arguing against the libertarian conception of a perfect minimal government (not because I agree with it but because this is a separate issue from the one you've raised). >You speak as if the government by default owns all my money, and I should be happy about what I am graciously permitted to keep. Actually, I didn't speak like that at all; you may be confusing me with a statist caricature. Which part of what I wrote are you referring to here? >Failing to make me less unhappy is perhaps in some sense increasing my happiness, So the legal system merely "fails to make you less [sic] unhappy"? I'm pretty sure it makes you happier in the ordinary sense of the phrase. I could choose many other examples, but I suspect that you are ideologically incapable of admitting that any government programs outside the bare libertarian minimum have made you any happier (whether or not this is in fact the case). I realize, having been on the internets for more that five minutes, that most libertarians are in favor of the government maintaining a legal system. Some of them are even willing to admit that they are happier as a result of its doing so. But this just goes to show that government-run things are not inherently bad and misery-causing, which is my point.