5 ms·
I always wondered what happens to quantum entanglement when time dilation is involved. For example if one of the particles falls into a black hole, can we get i
by EGreg 12y ago
I always wondered what happens to quantum entanglement when time dilation is involved. For example if one of the particles falls into a black hole, can we get info out?
- pavel_lishin 12y agoAs I understand it, you can't actually use this to transmit information. If you entangle two particles, and then send one away, and attempt to measure the appropriate property (I think it's spin), hurray: you know that the other particle's spin is the opposite. But that's not communication. It's like slicing a coin down the middle without looking at it, hiding each half in a box, and giving one of the boxes to someone going to the moon. A week later, you both open your box, and you know exactly which side of the coin the other person has - but that's not communication. (Someone smarter than me, please correct whatever mistakes I've made, and explain this in a better way.)
- beachwood23 12y agoWouldn't changing the spin be the way to communicate? Is spin not a changeable property?
- Igglyboo 12y agoNope, the spin isn't changeable and you cannot communicate via entaglement. If the spin was changeable however we'd have a long distance bit (0 or 1).
- EGreg 12y agoWikipedia says that spin can be changed: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spin_(physics) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spin_(physics) "Although the direction of its spin can be changed, an elementary particle cannot be made to spin faster or slower."
- stouset 12y agoSpin can be changed, but then you disentangle the two particles. So still no transmission of information.
- MrJagil 12y agoIsn't disentanglement a form of transmission of information? I.e. if suddenly my particle disentangles, I can assume it's been manipulated? (which is a binary state of tangled/untangles (0,1))
- zzalpha 12y agoAnd how can you tell if the particles are no longer entangled without observing both? It's not like there's some outward, observable property of the particle that says "I am entangled". It's simply a statistical correlation between the states of the two particles.
- MrJagil 12y agoInteresting. Excuse my ignorance(which is certainly present), just trying to learn. Can you expand on the last part about statistical correlation?
- ianburrell 12y agoThe correlation is that you know from your reading what the other person will detect. For example, if you detect a spin up particle, they will detect spin down. But you don't know when they have, or if they have, done the detection.
- zzalpha 12y agoSo, the statistical correlation between states of particles is literally the fundamental thing that defines quantum entanglement. Suppose you and I both get a coin and we flip them. You then turn over your hand and reveal heads. If the two coins are "entangled", there is now a greater than 50% probability that my coin will be tails, which would not be the case if the coins weren't entangled. Quantum entanglement works essentially the same way. "Flipping the coin" is equivalent to observing some state of the particle, like spin. In both cases, entanglement is evidenced by the correlation between the states, nothing more. Now, imagine we had entangled coins and we were in separate rooms. We flip our coins and you observe yours, noting a heads. In my room, I can't know what you did or didn't observe. So when I observe my coin and see tails, I don't realize it's a consequence of your observation. From each of our individual perspectives the coin flip looks perfectly random. This is why information transfer isn't possible through quantum entanglement.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoThat's the common explanation, but its apparently wrong. There is not a fixed state of each 'quarter' in each 'box'. They are truly not determined until one is resolved; then the other is resolved simultaneously. Still, not communication.
- sjeohp 12y ago> There is not a fixed state of each 'quarter' in each 'box'. They are truly not determined until one is resolved; Isn't that unknowable? And aren't both situations (fixed vs undetermined) effectively the same from an observer's point of view?
- sls 12y agoNo. What you are calling 'fixed' is a local hidden variable - an internal state that has yet to be measured but is already determined. This state of affairs is ruled out by Bell's Theorem - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell%27s_theorem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell%27s_theorem
- yohanatan 12y agoThat's only true if you take the Copenhagen interpretation. There are other interpretations (like 'consistent histories' for example). See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copenhagen_interpretation#Alternatives http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copenhagen_interpretation#Alter...
- om2 12y agoOther interpretations of quantum mechanics do not generally violate Bell's Theorem, since it appears to be confirmed by experiment. There are other interpretations which choose to abandon locality rather than hidden variables, such as the De Broglie-Bohm pilot wave interpretation. But consistent histories doesn't even do that. It's actually pretty similar to the Copenhagen interpretation.
- 12y ago
- sillysaurus3 12y agoIsn't it possible for the astronaut to also know whether the other person has opened their box? If yes, then this is where the analogy breaks down. However I'm probably remembering incorrectly. I just thought there was some property like "It's possible to detect whether the other person has made an observation yet." I'm probably mistaken, because if this were possible, then you could use it as a 1-bit communication. "If you detect that I've opened my box, then blow up the moon. Otherwise, do nothing." Time to re-study quantum mechanics... It's strange how easy it is to forget almost everything just by not thinking about it for two years. MIT OCW had some pretty great online courses on the subject.
- fragsworth 12y ago> Isn't it possible for the astronaut to also know whether the other person has opened their box? If yes, then this is where the analogy breaks down. The answer is no, and so the analogy doesn't break down. You can't observe the other person except by speed-of-light information transfer.
- tiglionabbit 12y agoI asked a similar question on physics stack exchange a few years ago, but I haven't seen a definitive answer. http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/8708/can-observations-of-entangled-particles-affect-their-unobserved-counterparts http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/8708/can-observat... If you ran two two-slit experiments on entangled particle pairs, shouldn't you be able to detect if your counterpart was observing theirs?
- Osmium 12y ago> Isn't it possible for the astronaut to also know whether the other person has opened their box? How would you know without observing the particle yourself? In which case, how do you know if it collapsed because of your observation or the other person's? Not an expert by any means, but from what I'm told you can't use it to transmit information, so that's how I think of it.
- VLM 12y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No-communication_theorem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No-communication_theorem Has a nice analogy, that being two radio listeners do know what each other are hearing which is cool, but can't communicate anything between them. I would have to think about the effect of creating a one time pad.
- dghughes 12y agoI've heard of that analogy before Brian Greene uses two boxes with a pair of gloves one box with the left glove and the other box the right glove. It's kind of like when you go to a doctor and have tests done for a disease if the results are bad, positive, they call you and if the results are negative no call. At some point a lab tech checks the sample and if it's negative for the disease they know at that moment but you know by the lack of information at some point in time; i.e. no phone call or letter. The negative results are more like the quantum communication due to the lack of interaction than the positive results. Mine may not be not the best analogy.
- biot 12y agoQuantum entanglement cannot communicate information, regardless of any other factors. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No-communication_theorem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No-communication_theorem
- Strilanc 12y agoProbably nothing more than usual. The local operations you can do to entangled particles are all commutative w.r.t. the operations applied by the other side. So whether they happened at the same time or before or after or slower or faster than the other side doesn't affect the local outcome (That should also make it clear why you can't use entanglement to communicate instantaneously: the other side must get the same results whether they measure before or after you've sent your message. So if entanglement allowed communication instead of just esoteric types of coordination, you could use it to send messages backwards in time.)