4 ms·
> blind hatred for the police Reactions to a detailed first person account are "blind"? What, pray tell, is your standard of acceptable sources for a debate?
by jjoonathan 12y ago
> blind hatred for the police
Reactions to a detailed first person account are "blind"? What, pray tell, is your standard of acceptable sources for a debate?
> I understand why cops are leery of having citizens pursue and enforce vigilante justice.
1. The victim of theft did not "enforce vigilante justice" even when the police refused to help him.
2. The victim of theft did not propose enforcing vigilante justice at any point in the process. All of his suggestions involved letting the police do their job while he assisted from a distance.
What are you trying to say? Because it sounds like you're accusing this guy of doing something he didn't do in order to avoid acknowledging that there is a problem.
> This could EASILY have led to a shootout.
Half of a policeman's duties could lead to shootouts. Should police everywhere avoid confronting criminals because such confrontations could lead to a shootout? No -- that would be ridiculous. Deciding that you aren't going to enforce petty theft laws because the cost/benefit is off is effectively equivalent to making petty theft legal. Even if this petty theft isn't important, you surely must acknowledge the importance of discouraging petty theft in general and the unsuitability of the "eh, not worth it" attitude for achieving that goal. The need for enforcement follows.
> I'd rather give [the police] the benefit of the doubt
It's very easy to pretend there isn't a problem when it doesn't affect you.
- Chevalier 12y agoSorry, but you're either deliberately or negligently misinterpreting my post. The cops ordered the author to stop pursuing the thieves, for fear of a shootout. They were not themselves afraid of shooting the thieves. The author seems to be quite correct in all his actions, and his anger is appropriate. The cops should have pursued his case, and their failure to do so is wrong. However, scan this thread for idiotic kneejerk reactions to the very existence of police. It may be fashionable to despise cops, but it's pretty damn stupid to hate the very thin blue line between you and truly awful people. Villainizing the profession is seems to be an emotional outlet for white guilt and class resentment. All most cops want from their jobs is a peaceful world where criminals don't run riot through decent people. Seattle PD failed to do their jobs in this case, and should step up enforcement of possible car break-ins -- but then the next HN story will be that cops are racist because they arrested felons for having car theft tools. Cops can't win.
- vezzy-fnord 12y agoVillainizing the profession is seems to be an emotional outlet for white guilt and class resentment. How in the hell? A lot of arguments against police come from libertarian perspectives: ones that reject such ideas grounded in identity politics to begin with. Right-wing perspectives, in other words. All most cops want from their jobs is a peaceful world where criminals don't run riot through decent people. You certainly do live in a very charitable world.
- sigstoat 12y ago> Seattle PD failed to do their jobs in this case, and should step up enforcement of possible car break-ins -- but then the next HN story will be that cops are racist because they arrested felons for having car theft tools. There's a nice wide middle ground between these two alternatives, where the cops arrest people when there is probable cause that they committed a specific crime.