4 ms·

My Grandma the Poisoner

51 points by GuiA 12y ago

eunoia 12y ago
That was an amazing read
personjerry 12y ago
This is a great work of fiction, but I don't feel it's relevant as HN content. What does everyone else think?
- notduncansmith 12y ago
  According to the guidelines, content is relevant if it is: > Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups. If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity
- goblin89 12y ago
  Do we consider a story fiction unless explicitly stated otherwise?
  - personjerry 12y ago
    I searched after beet recalls and found no such evidence anywhere
- johnloeber 12y ago
  The tags at the bottom read "personal history" and "personal essays", and there's no explicit indication that this is a piece of fiction. This might actually be (based on?) a real story.
- jpatokal 12y ago
  "Anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity" is on-topic at HN. Also, it's posted as a work of non-fiction.
- matthewmacleod 12y ago
  It's not fiction, as far as I'm aware. No need to be passive-aggressive about it. It was an interesting piece of writing, and that's enough.
  - personjerry 12y ago
    Well, I tried looking up the beet recall but it doesn't seem to have ever existed, so I made the assumption. As a side note, I actually rewrote my comment a few times because I thought I was being too passive-aggressive. Could you explain why it still seemed passive-aggressive and suggest a way to state it that would be less so?
- GuiA 12y ago
  I'm not posting this as OP, but as a very active HN user who has been on the site for a few years now: 99% of the time, comments that say "this doesn't belong on HN" on front page stories are more out of place than the story itself.
jxm262 12y ago
Wow , just wow.
johnloeber 12y ago
That was a really interesting read, but on the creepy/terrifying side of things. One line especially stood out to me: > When we announced my wife’s pregnancy, Grandma freaked out about how there’d be another mouth to feed and we couldn’t afford it. Assuming the miscarriage happened intentionally, as a consequence of Grandma's food, then I am taken aback by how this woman acted autonomously and intrusively, attempting to covertly control the lives of others, for their "benefit," because she "loved them." I suppose that's a remarkable example of the danger of not understanding boundaries: where social responsibilities end, and where dangerous overreach begins.
sunseb 12y ago
OMG
NhanH 12y ago
Since someone else was also thinking that the story seems too unbelievable, I looked up the "Canned beets and sunflower seeds" recall to see if it existed (and just because I was curious of what happened). Google search doesn't return anything meaningful for me. Does anyone know what incident that was?
- josu 12y ago
  The story sound like fiction to me, and it was posted just a couple of days before Halloween. I don't know, causing a miscarriage at that stage of the pregnancy too is not that simple. EDIT: The story was first published October 6 on the American edition of Vice and there is a metafilter thread about it http://www.metafilter.com/143959/What-do-you-do-when-you-think-you-have-a-murderer-in-the-family http://www.metafilter.com/143959/What-do-you-do-when-you-thi...
- VLM 12y ago
  The story also has some whoppers about scuba diving, and the replica of James Randi's blood of St Januarius deal (the red oil in a glass vial in a fancy container). And methane sprayed on an arm and set afire. It reads very realistic fictionally. I don't believe a word of it other than an impressionistic setting of mood and scene. That aspect of it is pretty good. There is a genre of lit where you put in technical errors so you can attack the people who notice them for not getting the point, that he loved his grandma although she was obsolete and toxic in the modern world although still physically barely living in it. Yeah author, I get it, you don't have to put intentional errors in it so your little english lit buddies can feel all superior when the unwashed masses of "nerds" find it full of mistakes. Much like hollywood intentionally screwing up everything involving computers because it'll only offend nerds.

51 points by GuiA 12y ago

eunoia 12y ago

That was an amazing read

personjerry 12y ago

This is a great work of fiction, but I don't feel it's relevant as HN content. What does everyone else think?

notduncansmith 12y ago
According to the guidelines, content is relevant if it is: > Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups. If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity
goblin89 12y ago
Do we consider a story fiction unless explicitly stated otherwise?
- personjerry 12y ago
  I searched after beet recalls and found no such evidence anywhere
johnloeber 12y ago
The tags at the bottom read "personal history" and "personal essays", and there's no explicit indication that this is a piece of fiction. This might actually be (based on?) a real story.
jpatokal 12y ago
"Anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity" is on-topic at HN. Also, it's posted as a work of non-fiction.
matthewmacleod 12y ago
It's not fiction, as far as I'm aware. No need to be passive-aggressive about it. It was an interesting piece of writing, and that's enough.
- personjerry 12y ago
  Well, I tried looking up the beet recall but it doesn't seem to have ever existed, so I made the assumption. As a side note, I actually rewrote my comment a few times because I thought I was being too passive-aggressive. Could you explain why it still seemed passive-aggressive and suggest a way to state it that would be less so?
GuiA 12y ago
I'm not posting this as OP, but as a very active HN user who has been on the site for a few years now: 99% of the time, comments that say "this doesn't belong on HN" on front page stories are more out of place than the story itself.

jxm262 12y ago

Wow , just wow.

johnloeber 12y ago

That was a really interesting read, but on the creepy/terrifying side of things. One line especially stood out to me: > When we announced my wife’s pregnancy, Grandma freaked out about how there’d be another mouth to feed and we couldn’t afford it. Assuming the miscarriage happened intentionally, as a consequence of Grandma's food, then I am taken aback by how this woman acted autonomously and intrusively, attempting to covertly control the lives of others, for their "benefit," because she "loved them." I suppose that's a remarkable example of the danger of not understanding boundaries: where social responsibilities end, and where dangerous overreach begins.

sunseb 12y ago

OMG

NhanH 12y ago

Since someone else was also thinking that the story seems too unbelievable, I looked up the "Canned beets and sunflower seeds" recall to see if it existed (and just because I was curious of what happened). Google search doesn't return anything meaningful for me. Does anyone know what incident that was?

josu 12y ago
The story sound like fiction to me, and it was posted just a couple of days before Halloween. I don't know, causing a miscarriage at that stage of the pregnancy too is not that simple. EDIT: The story was first published October 6 on the American edition of Vice and there is a metafilter thread about it http://www.metafilter.com/143959/What-do-you-do-when-you-think-you-have-a-murderer-in-the-family http://www.metafilter.com/143959/What-do-you-do-when-you-thi...
VLM 12y ago
The story also has some whoppers about scuba diving, and the replica of James Randi's blood of St Januarius deal (the red oil in a glass vial in a fancy container). And methane sprayed on an arm and set afire. It reads very realistic fictionally. I don't believe a word of it other than an impressionistic setting of mood and scene. That aspect of it is pretty good. There is a genre of lit where you put in technical errors so you can attack the people who notice them for not getting the point, that he loved his grandma although she was obsolete and toxic in the modern world although still physically barely living in it. Yeah author, I get it, you don't have to put intentional errors in it so your little english lit buddies can feel all superior when the unwashed masses of "nerds" find it full of mistakes. Much like hollywood intentionally screwing up everything involving computers because it'll only offend nerds.