3 ms·
I'm not sure why everyone seems to think carrier subsidies are a con. I don't think it's a con, and I understand why the carriers price the phones this way: it
by nkurz 12y ago
I'm not sure why everyone seems to think carrier subsidies are a con.
I don't think it's a con, and I understand why the carriers price the phones this way: it works! But I'm baffled why consumers and reporters seem comfortable comparing the 'with contract' prices of phones as if the upfront difference between 99 cents, $99, $199, and $299 is the best way to decide with which company to sign a $2000 two-year contract.
Amazon isn't getting that $1000+, they get whatever the non-contract price is of the phone. Carriers subsidize some of that cost in-exchange for some guaranteed cash flow for 2 years.
Yes, Amazon collects whatever amount they convince the customer to pay for the phone, plus a much larger 'kickback' from the carrier in return for getting them to sign a two-year contract. My expectation was that an article in a financially oriented magazine about the losses Amazon was experiencing might make some mention of the several hundred dollars[1] Amazon collects from the carrier rather than concentrating only on the '99 cent' sticker price.
I had a confused conversation last week with someone who expressed delight that her new iPhone 6 cost about the same as my "no contract" Moto G. She was surprised to learn that if she broke or lost her phone it would cost more than the "discount" price to replace. And she's a very savvy consumer, has a science PhD, and her husband works for Apple! She probably would have 'bought' the same phone in either case, but if the details of the arrangement weren't clear to her, I doubt that most consumers have a very good understanding of how phone pricing works. My lament was that after reading this Fortune article neither she nor anyone else would have an improved understanding.
[1] What is the actual amount that Amazon collects from the carrier?