5 ms·
This article doesn't get the internet. I think it's spurious and mendacious to suggest that consumers upload amounts of data that are in any way comparable to
by barrkel 12y ago
This article doesn't get the internet.
I think it's spurious and mendacious to suggest that consumers upload amounts of data that are in any way comparable to the amount downloaded by people who stream HD video for live consumption.
I'm not particularly pleased about putting content consumers and content producers into two separate boxes, but the classifications of internet endpoints definitely exists in the usage patterns we have today.
Unless the security and privacy problems of the cloud are fixed, people are unlikely to upload the kind of data required to make them comparable - the only thing I can think of that could make it happen is life streaming or continuous security footage across multiple cameras. But I think cloud storage's problems are increasing, not decreasing, and they'll continue to increase until we get to the bottom of the tension with government spying and commercial exploitation of user privacy.
I think net neutrality, as it's naively presented, is highly unfair and subsidizes people who consume a lot of content at the expense of people who only use the internet occasionally. Flat rates for all you can eat downloads, combined with necessarily oversold capacity (since most people don't use all their available capacity all the time), inevitably means that high usage consumers are subsidized by low usage consumers.
There's two ways to make this fairer. Charge people based on how much they download - i.e. caps and overage charges, as horrible as that sounds - or charge companies that upload data more, who can then pass on those costs to their customers. The market has generally rejected the first solution. It's now trying the second solution. But either way is better than network neutrality.
And I say that as a person for whom "network neutrality" is in their interest. But I can see that it's plainly and patently unfair.
- altcognito 12y ago> Unless the security and privacy problems of the cloud are fixed, people are unlikely to upload the kind of data required to make them comparable You vastly overestimate people's concern over privacy and security. We still use email, http and insecure credit cards yet they have huge security and privacy holes. People will use what appeals to them and worry about security and privacy generally later.
- freshflowers 12y agoYour argument has absolutely nothing to do with net neutrality. Charging people for consumed volume is something that can and does already happen, and continues to happen in places where net neutrality is law. Net neutrality is about not discriminating in what people consume or send. BTW, high volume traffic companies like Netflix and YouTube are outliers. Many ordinary end users create way more upstream traffic than the average commercial non-video content provider.
- barrkel 12y agoIt has everything to do with net neutrality. See my reply to eli for the reason why (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8547054 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8547054).
- pdonis 12y ago> Flat rates for all you can eat downloads, combined with necessarily oversold capacity (since most people don't use all their available capacity all the time) What does this have to do with net neutrality? Net neutrality is not about how much data gets transferred. It's about not privileging some data types or data sources over others. Charging higher fees for more bandwidth usage is fine, and completely consistent with net neutrality. Charging someone who streams 100 GB/month from Netflix more than someone who streams 100 GB/month from Redbox or Hulu is not. > The market has generally rejected the first solution. No, ISPs have generally rejected the first solution, because if people who only used small amounts of bandwidth only got charged for small amounts of bandwidth, the ISPs would get less revenue. They are able to get away with this because the market for internet access in most places in the US is not free: ISPs have sweetheart deals with local governments giving them exclusive access. (And every time a local municipality tries to build out broadband as a public utility, with equal access for any ISP, the big ISPs have kittens and take them to court.)
- barrkel 12y ago> ISPs have generally rejected the first solution I think ISPs like segmented pricing models. Segmented pricing models let them extract more profits from sections of the market that can afford more. But segmentation by bandwidth cap doesn't seem to be very successful. > Charging someone who streams 100 GB/month from Netflix more than someone who streams 100 GB/month from Redbox or Hulu is not. Just to get some reality into these figures; on a 5Mbit line, 300G/month was typical for our house. Now that we have an 80Mbit line, I would expect our home usage is now well in excess of 1T/month. (I live in the UK.) This should tell you that I have no self-interest in bandwidth caps, especially joke 2-figure ones. Given that, I agree that there shouldn't, in principle, be a distinction between packets from company A vs company B. But without being able to efficiently price the scarce resource via bandwidth caps and segmented pricing models on the consumer side, the ISP is reduced to negotiating with the upstream providers of packets that are consuming the scarce resource on behalf of their customers. It then becomes a business negotiation problem, with contracts, leverage and relative power. So naturally there will be variance in which company pays what. Somebody has got to pay for the scarce resources being exhasuted. That person will be the consumer who downloads more. The only question is how the payment will be routed.
- randomdata 12y ago> I think it's spurious and mendacious to suggest that consumers upload amounts of data that are in any way comparable to the amount downloaded by people who stream HD video for live consumption. How much of that is a result of the existing infrastructure? My available upload bandwidth is just 10% of my download bandwidth, which makes it pretty much useless for all but tiny amounts of data. There are many things I would love to upload, but it is just not feasible, so you learn to deal with it.
- barrkel 12y ago10% of my upload bandwidth is a megabyte a second. That's enough for most of my upload usage - backup primarily, and the occasional youtube video. Your perspective on upload vs download may change a bit when your connection gets better. I think a 9:1 ratio of download to upload is the right thing for most consumers. Ideally, the connection would rebalance based on demand, but I don't know enough about xDSL technology to know why that isn't possible.
- eli 12y agoNet neutrality does not preclude metered access. Two different things.
- barrkel 12y agoLet me try and explain why these things are related with some economics. There is a scarce resource, consumer bandwidth. We normally use pricing to communicate information about scarce resources. This has the advantage of increasing the profitability of investment in increasing the supply of the scarce resource. The explosion in growth in streaming HD video services has meant that the statistical variance of consumer bandwidth consumption from mean consumption has increased. If most pricing models assume a mean usage, that means that heavy users are now being subsidized more than before by light users. For fairness, heavy users should be charged more. That can be done via metered access with higher allowances costing more, or it can be done by charging more for the streams of data that are consuming the scarce resource. That means Netflix and their ilk. But of course Netflix will pass on any extra cost on to the customer. These are two sides of the same coin. If metered access with segmented pricing can't solve the pricing problem, then contracts with suppliers of data streams will be used instead.
- lutorm 12y agoAre you suggesting a system where, instead of settlement-free peering, peering between networks is on a pay-per-bit basis? I suppose that would also be consistent with neutrality, as long as there is no discrimination between networks. In no instance should Netflix have to pay anything to anyone except their access provider.
- barrkel 12y agoThe trouble is that the cost of a packet is a function of its entire route, not simply size or quantity. The more packets that flow through a congested hop, the more that flow should be charged (whether to the sender or recipient). Peering with a network where the packets are not due to go through heavily contended routes shouldn't be a big problem, and nor should peering with a network where the routes for packets being interchanged have similar constraints. Probably, a totally fair system would involve so much accounting that most of the cost would be dominated by it. Let's not also forget that Netflix et al. don't always rely on peering. They can give their customers a better experience by directly attaching hardware to the ISP's network, i.e. edge caching, which itself involves contracts and negotiation, independent of any network neutrality concerns around packets swapped at peering.