5 ms·
Cantonese Proverbs in One Picture
- Rygu 12y agoHilariously effective education. It's also a great display of the Cantonese' history, culture, and (wise) humor. Wonderful!
- cauliturtle 12y agoas a Hongkonger here, karma to support
- thisjepisje 12y agoPieter Bruegel - Netherlandish Proverbs (1559) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Netherlandish_Proverbs http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Netherlandish_Proverbs
- farva 12y agoShaka, when the walls fell.
- toisanji 12y agoup vote from hk!
- tacon 12y agoI don't speak Chinese at all, but my understanding is that the writing is common, only the sounds vary from Mandarin to Cantonese. So how does a piece of writing like this help to preserve Cantonese? I would think that would take a song or spoken prose or something audible to maintain the Cantonese dialect. In five hundred years, if Cantonese speaking people have disappeared, will Mandarin speakers be able to read this graphic?
- Gigablah 12y agoNot quite. A simple example: "冇" (meaning "don't have") is not present in Mandarin. You can find a list here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Written_Cantonese http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Written_Cantonese
- quantisan 12y agoCantonese speaker here. These are Cantonese (the region) proverbs much like "Bob's Your Uncle" is a quintessentially British saying that Americans wouldn't understand. On another note, mainland China (including Canton) actually uses simplified Chinese writing (which came out from the Deng Xiao Ping era) whereas Hong Kong specifically maintians the traditional writing. The difference is literally less strokes and simplification of the characters. The infographic here uses the traditional writing. Personally I feel the two writings are mostly close enough that people should be able to guess what the other means. And AFAIK, it's a 1-to-1 mapping anyway.
- lpsz 12y agoIn the meantime, Taiwan maintains traditional Chinese writing while using Mandarin for speech. Table for clarity: Simplified + Mandarin -> Mainland China Traditional + Cantonese -> Hong Kong, Macau Traditional + Mandarin -> Taiwan
- yzzxy 12y agoSome of these proverbs are known in mainland China however. 隔墙有耳 for example is a Mandarin saying as well (though perhaps derived from original Cantonese?).
- spacehunt 12y agoIt's actually a many-to-one mapping - going from traditional to simplified loses information, and people have to resort to natural language processing algorithms (mainly n-grams) when going back the other way. Also, many of the "simplifications" are based on Mandarin pronunciations, and were quite incomprehensible to me as a Cantonese speaker when I set foot into mainland China for the first time years ago.
- quantisan 12y agoI want to make a correction. It's actually Mao Zedong and not Deng Xiao Ping, which held power much later.
- aboodman 12y agoIt's missing my favorite one: http://www.cantonese.sheik.co.uk/dictionary/words/45161/ http://www.cantonese.sheik.co.uk/dictionary/words/45161/
- tokenadult 12y agoHere is an example of a plausible conversation in Mandarin and a plausible conversation in Cantonese to show how different the two languages are, with different words (not cognate, and thus not written with the same Chinese character) in places even where you would expect English and German, or Spanish and French, to be cognate. I checked the example dialogues against dialogues posted online by native speakers of each of the languages, both for accuracy in transcribing the Chinese characters and for natural idiomatic expression in each language. How you might write the conversation "Does he know how to speak Mandarin? "No, he doesn't." 他會說普通話嗎? 他不會。 in Modern Standard Chinese characters contrasts with how you would write "Does he know how to speak Cantonese? "No, he doesn't." 佢識唔識講廣東話? 佢唔識。 in the Chinese characters used to write Cantonese. As will readily appear even to readers who don't know Chinese characters, many more words than "Mandarin" and "Cantonese" differ between those sentences in Chinese characters. Chinese characters still represent SPEECH (not ideas or abstract concepts) and do so in a way that is specific to the particular Chinese (Sinitic) language that one speaks. The long story about this can be found in the books The Chinese Language: Fact and Fantasy[1] or Visible Speech: The Diverse Oneness of Writing Systems[2] by the late John DeFrancis or the book Ideogram: Chinese Characters and the Myth of Disembodied Meaning[3] by J. Marshall Unger. The book Reading in the Brain: The Science and Evolution of a Human Invention[4] by Stanislas Dehaene is a very good book about reading in general, and has a good cross-cultural perspective. Many other examples of words, phrases, and whole sentences that are essentially unreadable to persons who have learned only Modern Standard Chinese can be found in texts produced in Chinese characters by speakers of other Sinitic languages ("Chinese dialects"). Similar considerations apply to Japanese, which is not even a language cognate with Chinese, and also links Chinese characters to particular speech morphemes (whether etymologically Japanese or Sino-Japanese) rather than with abstract concepts. [1] http://www.amazon.com/Chinese-Language-Fantasy-John-DeFrancis/dp/0824810686/ http://www.amazon.com/Chinese-Language-Fantasy-John-DeFranci... [2] http://www.amazon.com/Visible-Speech-Asian-Interactions-Comparisons/dp/0824812077/ http://www.amazon.com/Visible-Speech-Asian-Interactions-Comp... [3] http://www.amazon.com/Ideogram-Chinese-Characters-Disembodied-Meaning/dp/0824827600/ http://www.amazon.com/Ideogram-Chinese-Characters-Disembodie... [4] http://readinginthebrain.pagesperso-orange.fr/intro.htm http://readinginthebrain.pagesperso-orange.fr/intro.htm
- 12y ago
- acangiano 12y ago"Use a little knife to saw down a tree" is wonderful and relevant to the audience here.
- oneeyedpigeon 12y agoI would never have guessed the actual meaning of that. It sounds negative, as if it would mean "using the wrong (underpowered) tool for the job", but I'm guess I'm taking it too literally!
- archibaldJ 12y agoCantonese native speaker here. Just want to state that the definitions for the expression 飛象過河 (An elephant flies across the river) 1. To break a rule 2. To reach across the table for food are both a reference to a rule in Chinese chess stating that 象 (elephant) is a defensive piece and cannot cross the river, with the latter being more of a metaphor to describe someone who reaches across the table for food, which is considered a bad table manner.
- hbc 12y ago笋嘢!
- shangxiao 12y agoThose sound clips are killing the page load... Aside from that this is quite good. I feel like some of these proverbs could be quoted here on HN comment threads.
- sparkzilla 12y agoWhen I was in elementary school we had one of these for English proverbs. I checked on Google images but don't see anything like it.
- nhoven 12y agoI remember my mom teaching me the phrase "like dragging a cow up a tree" when I was little, and I was never sure whether she was serious. I was very excited to see it captured here! Mom, I'm sorry for not trusting you.
- known 12y ago"Give a man a fish and he will eat for a day. Teach a man to fish and he will eat for a lifetime. " -Confucius