3 ms·
I think it's absurd that people are legally prevented from purchasing drugs that haven't been FDA approved. I think it is reasonable to e.g. force companies to
by wyager 12y ago
I think it's absurd that people are legally prevented from purchasing drugs that haven't been FDA approved. I think it is reasonable to e.g. force companies to put "Not FDA approved", but I don't think it's reasonable to preclude sale at all.
There are a number of medical treatments that have been proven safe to EMA (the European version of the FDA) standards, but were either mired for further years in the FDA approval process or were never approved at all due to the increased complexity and cost of the FDA approval process. Take a look at http://www.bioworld.com/content/ema-trounces-fda-2013-drug-approval-tally-81-vs-27 http://www.bioworld.com/content/ema-trounces-fda-2013-drug-a... to see the disparity.
The argument I always hear against allowing people to purchase drugs that haven't been officially approved by whatever agency has jurisdiction over the patient is "But what if some unscrupulous drug salesman bamboozles them into buying snake oil?". It seems to me that the existence of the FDA, EMA, and any number of other national and private certifying bodies is more than sufficient to allow people to make an informed decision for themselves.
I think that any argument for drug decriminalization or bodily sanctity can be applied in favor of allowing people to choose what drugs they wish to consume (even though some people will make unwise choices).
- WalterBright 12y agoA straightforward approach is that legally consenting adults can use non-FDA approved drugs if they sign a consent form specifically acknowledging that a drug is not approved by the FDA. Heck, require it to be notarized. A carrot to get FDA approval for a drug can be that the drug maker is shielded from liability for side effects of the drug. (Of course, the shield wouldn't apply if the drug maker misrepresented the drug during the approval process, or did not make the drug correctly.)
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- serf 12y ago> I think it's absurd that people are legally prevented from purchasing drugs that haven't been FDA approved. They aren't. In the U.S. they are prevented from purchasing certain drugs without the advice and consent of a prescribing physician. The prescribing physician can be on-board for the use of non-FDA approved meds, it's just uncommon. source : personal anecdote. I used 4-Aminopyridine[0] with the consent of my doctor within the US before clinical trials began as a 'research tool' for insights into a medical condition. It was dispensed by a medical chemistry lab under the consent of my physician, and paid for out of pocket. [0]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/4-Aminopyridine http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/4-Aminopyridine
- wyager 12y ago> The prescribing physician can be on-board for the use of non-FDA approved meds, it's just uncommon. This seems to be essentially false. I can find some evidence that unapproved drugs are prescribed in the US, but this is usually because A) the drug is grandfathered in or B) the doctor is breaking the law (intentionally or unintentionally). http://www.fda.gov/drugs/guidancecomplianceregulatoryinformation/enforcementactivitiesbyfda/selectedenforcementactionsonunapproveddrugs/default.htm http://www.fda.gov/drugs/guidancecomplianceregulatoryinforma... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Drug_Application http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Drug_Application http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Investigational_New_Drug http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Investigational_New_Drug http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kefauver_Harris_Amendment http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kefauver_Harris_Amendment Also, the FDA approved 4-Aminopyridine in 2010. http://www.fda.gov/NewsEvents/Newsroom/PressAnnouncements/ucm198463.htm http://www.fda.gov/NewsEvents/Newsroom/PressAnnouncements/uc...
- tel 12y agoMy (partial) understanding is that the FDA merely limits the ability for someone to market a drug prior to approval. A prescribing doctor could, should they choose, decide to prescribe a non-FDA-approved drug... but it would be difficult for anyone to find it if it wasn't a natural remedy. Without marketing and mass adoption is hard to fund the manufacturing process for a drug.
- coldtea 12y ago>I think it's absurd that people are legally prevented from purchasing drugs that haven't been FDA approved. I think it is reasonable to e.g. force companies to put "Not FDA approved", but I don't think it's reasonable to preclude sale at all. Whay would happen is the snake oil industry would get huge, and all accountability will be lost. The drug industry after all WAS unregulated in the past. >* It seems to me that the existence of the FDA, EMA, and any number of other national and private certifying bodies is more than sufficient to allow people to make an informed decision for themselves.* You'd be surprised. People already fall for all kind of BS "snake oil" remedies and magic pill solutions (not to mention stuff like homeopathy and aromatherapy, etc). What would happen in that case will be that they would consider FDA some "bureucratic, antiquated" organization, that is "too slow" to respond to new drug needs etc. And of course all the propaganda from the snake oil salesmen will help in this. Plus, remember the thamilomide baby situation back in the fifties? That would be a much more frequent occurence with non FDA approved drugs.
- robbiep 12y agoI hate it when people reply as I am about to, but: > Whay would happen is the snake oil industry would get huge, and all accountability will be lost. The drug industry after all WAS unregulated in the past. This
- wyager 12y ago>People already fall for all kind of BS "snake oil" remedies and magic pill solutions (not to mention stuff like homeopathy and aromatherapy, etc). That's fair. But is protecting these people from their own stupidity sufficient justification to possibly promote unnecessary suffering and prevent people from accessing needed/wanted medication?
- dllthomas 12y ago"You'd be surprised. People already fall for all kind of BS "snake oil" remedies and magic pill solutions (not to mention stuff like homeopathy and aromatherapy, etc)." I think a big question is whether this would get any worse. I think that it would, but I am not exceedingly confident about that.
- streptomycin 12y agoHere's another argument against your idea, completely unrelated to the snake oil rebuttal: If patients could just buy unapproved drugs directly, why would they sign up for a clinical trial where there is a good chance they get the placebo? Keep in mind that even if there are a lot of people taking a drug, it is incredibly difficult to see if it actually works without a randomized controlled trial. And a big problem with clinical trials today is recruiting enough patients for the trial. It's difficult and expensive. If the pool of patients wanting to enter the trial was smaller, less trials would get run and we would learn less about which drugs actually work and which don't.
- wyager 12y ago>why would they sign up for a clinical trial where there is a good chance they get the placebo? Two reasons. 1. They might be too poor to afford the drug. 2. The drug company has an incentive not to release the drug before being officially approved, for reasons of CYA and reputation.